Professional Scepticism in IPOs: HKSI Paper 15
For an IPO sponsor, professional scepticism means testing statements with a questioning mind, looking for contradictory evidence and checking what each source actually proves.
- It is neither automatic distrust nor blind reliance on management or experts.
- The sponsor should expand inquiries when material facts, assumptions or disclosure remain unsupported.
On this page8 sections
- What professional scepticism means for a sponsor
- Start with assertions and competing explanations
- Recognize warning signs without jumping to a verdict
- Challenge management explanations constructively
- Treat expert information as evidence to assess
- Document how the conclusion was reached
- Worked case: test a year-end revenue surge
- Common traps in an exam answer
- Meaning
- Critical assessment with a questioning mind
- Sponsor setting
- Challenge accuracy and completeness of applicant statements and information
- Trigger
- Contradictions, limitations, implausible trends or unsupported assumptions
- Principal role
- Ensure diligence scope and resources address risks; evaluate and resolve findings
- Exam application
- Choose inquiries that test the claim and its basis
What professional scepticism means for a sponsor
Professional scepticism is a working attitude, not an accusation that management is dishonest. HKEX Practice Note 21 describes it as a critical assessment with a questioning mind and awareness of information, including expert information, that contradicts or calls into question the reliability of representations. For a sponsor, the practical question is: what evidence would make this statement reliable, what might disprove it, and what else should we expect to see if it is true?
The sponsor’s task is not to rubber-stamp the issuer’s narrative. It must make inquiries sufficient to support its own regulatory responsibilities and assess the listing document. A management explanation can be a useful lead, but it is not independent proof. A signed contract, bank transfer, expert report or internal report can each support part of a claim while leaving other parts untested. Skeptical work identifies those boundaries and tests them against the claim being made.
A questioning mind is compatible with fair treatment. The sponsor should listen to management, understand context and avoid assuming an adverse conclusion from one anomaly. But it should also avoid deciding too early that the anomaly is harmless. Record what is known, what remains uncertain, which explanations are plausible and what evidence can distinguish among them. The conclusion should follow the evidence, not the preferred timetable or the attractiveness of the deal.
Start with assertions and competing explanations
Take a statement from the draft prospectus and identify its hidden assertions. “We have a diversified customer base” may imply that customers are independent, that no one relationship dominates sales, and that the pattern is stable over time. “Demand is resilient” may imply repeat purchases across market conditions, not merely a large order before year end. Convert each statement into testable questions with a defined period and scope.
Then list plausible explanations that could weaken the assertion. Revenue growth may reflect genuine new demand, price increases, an acquisition, a one-off bulk order, extended payment terms or shipments later returned. Rising margins may reflect efficiency, product mix, a temporary input-cost benefit or capitalized expenses. The purpose is not to enumerate every imaginable scenario. It is to identify reasonable alternatives given the facts and design work that can distinguish them.
For each claim, choose corroboration independent enough to add information. If management says an order was delivered, inspect delivery and acceptance evidence and compare it with inventory and logistics records. If the assertion is customer concentration, reconcile customer-level sales to the ledger, identify related parties and inspect collection. If the statement concerns market leadership, define the relevant market and source the comparison. Repeating the assertion in an interview or management certificate does not independently corroborate it.
A useful inquiry record has four parts: the claim and why it matters; the evidence obtained; contradictions or limitations; and the conclusion with remaining uncertainty. It should also show who reviewed the work and what follow-up was done. This structure is more informative than a checklist with every box ticked and no explanation of what a source demonstrated.
Recognize warning signs without jumping to a verdict
An anomaly is a reason to ask more, not automatic proof of misconduct. Unusual growth before filing, a large year-end order, repeated round-number adjustments, high receivables, customer concentration, related-party dealings, key-person dependence or a sudden change in accounting policy can each have a legitimate explanation. The sponsor should assess size, timing, recurrence, counterparties and consistency with other information. The work becomes more extensive when the potential effect on eligibility, financial performance or disclosure is material.
A simple reasonableness check can expose gaps. Compare sales growth with capacity, staffing, purchase volumes, market conditions and collection. If revenue doubles but units shipped, factory output and receivables do not move, ask what drives the difference. If the applicant explains that prices rose, compare price and volume separately and check whether the product mix changed. When the explanation relies on a new market, examine the applicant’s entry date, licences, customers, operating resources and costs.
Timing can also change the meaning of evidence. A payment received after year end may support collectability but cannot alone prove the goods were delivered or control transferred by the earlier date. A customer renewal can support a forecast only if the contract and conditions match the assumption. A site visit after a major expansion does not establish the historic capacity used in prior periods. Label the relevant date and period in every conclusion.
Consider management incentives and information flow. Does the person answering have direct knowledge? Could remuneration, ownership or a transaction deadline affect the explanation? Are finance staff giving a different account from sales or operations? A discrepancy may result from different definitions or reporting dates, but the sponsor should reconcile it. Avoid letting hierarchy decide which version is true without evidence.
Challenge management explanations constructively
Ask open questions first. “Walk us through how this order was recorded from contract to cash” often reveals process details that “Was the sale genuine?” will not. Then narrow the inquiry: who authorized a discount, what delivery condition applied, which customer representative approved acceptance, and what happened after invoice? Give management an opportunity to explain contrary evidence, then test the explanation independently. A fair process is rigorous and transparent about what remains unresolved.
Use follow-up questions that examine the basis of the explanation. If management attributes a margin increase to efficiency, ask which process changed, when it was introduced, what cost categories moved and whether output quality or staffing changed. Compare the account with operational records and budgets. If a one-off benefit is included in a future forecast, ask why it recurs. Record both management’s response and the evidence that supports or contradicts it.
When more than one reasonable explanation remains, do not disguise the uncertainty. Consider additional testing, qualified wording, disclosure of the alternative risk, or escalation to a committee. If the uncertainty is material and cannot be resolved, the sponsor may need to delay or reconsider proceeding. The fact that management accepts a risk factor does not necessarily make a core disclosure accurate.
Professional scepticism is also required inside the sponsor firm. Analysts should be able to report concerns to the Principal without fear that raising them will be treated as disloyalty to the deal. Reviewers should ask what evidence supports a conclusion and whether adverse findings were cleared for a reason. A culture that rewards speed or low comment counts can suppress the very information the sponsor needs.
Treat expert information as evidence to assess
An expert can provide specialized knowledge, but the sponsor still has to examine whether the expert is appropriate and whether the work answers the relevant question. Look at qualifications, experience, resources, independence, engagement terms, scope, assumptions and data sources. Consider whether management or the sponsor supplied information that may shape the opinion. If the report excludes a major site, product, liability or risk the sponsor knows about, ask why and assess whether its scope remains fit for purpose.
A sponsor need not replicate a technical calculation outside its expertise. It should understand the report’s logic well enough to identify limitations and inconsistency. Ask the expert to explain the methodology, assumptions, sensitivity and any reliance on applicant data. Verify factual inputs that the expert did not verify itself, in a manner appropriate for a non-expert sponsor. Confirm that the prospectus describes the expert’s work fairly and does not imply broader assurance than the report gives.
For example, a market study may conclude that the applicant’s addressable market is growing, based on a database that excludes informal channels. The sponsor should understand the dataset, definition, period, exclusions and assumptions. If management’s business plan depends on selling into those excluded channels, the team needs to assess that limitation and revise the narrative or forecast. The expert’s presence does not convert a contestable assumption into a fact.
Document how the conclusion was reached
Records should capture the significant inquiry and its reasoning. Preserve interview notes, source documents, contradictory data, review comments, issue escalation, management responses and closure evidence. A short conclusion such as “satisfied” is not enough for a complex judgement. Explain which facts were decisive, what alternatives were considered and why remaining risks do not make the disclosure misleading. If an issue was referred to senior management, record the decision and subsequent action.
Verification schedules can reinforce scepticism by forcing the team to connect precise wording with support. For each statement, identify its source and what that source proves. A source may verify a date but not a characterization; a contract may prove terms but not performance; a registry may prove a filing but not ongoing compliance. Mark gaps honestly and do not let a general source reference imply full verification.
The Principal should be involved when significant questions arise. The Principal helps determine scope and resourcing, evaluates the results and ensures issues are resolved. Escalation is especially important for reputational matters, material changes and findings that affect applicant suitability or a sponsor declaration. A recorded dissent or unresolved objection should not disappear during drafting.
Worked case: test a year-end revenue surge
An applicant’s revenue rises sharply in the final month before a listing submission. Management says it reflects seasonal demand. The sponsor team finds that a major distributor placed the orders, paid a small deposit, and asked for return rights after year end. What should the sponsor conclude?
A distributor’s year-end orders drove a revenue surge. Delivery was after period end, only a deposit was paid, and the distributor later asked for return rights. What is the best response?
- Accept management’s seasonal explanation because there is a signed order.
- Investigate delivery, acceptance, cut-off, payment, return terms and side agreements; assess the accounting and disclosure implications before relying on the sales figure.
- Ignore later correspondence because it came after the reporting date.
- Disclose the risk but leave the reported revenue unchanged without further work.
A proper next step could include checking dispatch records, customer acceptance, inventory movement, subsequent credit notes, payment and return correspondence, accounting cut-off and comparable transactions. The team should ask whether the arrangement is isolated or part of a broader practice. Depending on the findings, the reported period, revenue amount, concentration analysis and forecast assumptions may need correction. The decision and evidence should reach the Principal and the proper internal escalation route.
Common traps in an exam answer
Do not confuse scepticism with cynicism. The sponsor should not reject every management explanation automatically. It should test plausible explanations and follow the evidence. Do not confuse professional reliance with blind reliance: experts have defined scopes and do not remove the sponsor’s own responsibilities. Do not confuse obtaining a signed confirmation with corroboration. The correct inquiry is the one that tests the relevant assertion with reliable evidence.
Do not use a fixed checklist as the conclusion. Practice Note 21 describes typical inquiries, and appropriate work may be more extensive in a particular case. A candidate should identify the risk and explain why a procedure addresses it. “Interview customers” is incomplete if the answer never explains which claim the interview tests or how the response will be corroborated.
Finally, do not treat a tight timetable as a reason to waive essential diligence. If a matter cannot be resolved, explain the gap, escalate and assess whether disclosure or timing must change. A sponsor’s gatekeeping role depends on accurate, complete and non-misleading information, not merely on submitting a document by a planned date.
Scepticism means testing according to risk, not assuming misconduct. A low value routine expense may need limited corroboration; revenue concentration that drives forecast viability requires more. Record what was verified and why residual uncertainty is acceptable or requires escalation. Treat contrary evidence fairly and avoid selectively recording facts that support the preferred conclusion.
An expert may inherit management assumptions. If a market report uses an applicant customer list, ask whether customers were independently confirmed, how inactive accounts were treated and whether competitors were omitted. Read the scope and limitations. The sponsor must understand enough of the method to assess whether it supports the proposed disclosure.
A balanced record includes evidence that supports and contradicts the applicant’s position. If a customer confirmation supports sales but subsequent returns undermine them, retain both and explain the resolution. If an external search finds a related party link, record how management responded and what independent checks followed. Selective workpapers can make an unsupported conclusion appear settled. Scepticism is demonstrated by the inquiry and fair assessment, not by hostile language toward management.
Common questions
Does professional scepticism mean assuming management is dishonest?
No. It means critically assessing statements with a questioning mind and testing reliability, including by noticing contradictory or incomplete information.
Can an expert’s report replace sponsor due diligence?
No. The sponsor should assess the expert’s qualifications, scope, assumptions and data, investigate contradictions and ensure the report is fairly presented.
What should a sponsor do when evidence conflicts?
Investigate the discrepancy, obtain appropriate corroboration, assess its effect on disclosure and escalate material unresolved matters before relying on the statement.
Is Practice Note 21 an exhaustive procedure list?
No. It gives typical Main Board inquiries, but the sponsor must tailor scope and depth to each applicant and transaction.