Experts in IPO Due Diligence: HKSI Paper 15
Sponsors may rely on specialist expertise, but they must assess the expert’s qualifications, resources, independence, scope, assumptions and factual inputs.
- They should investigate contradictions, verify material facts the expert did not check and ensure the prospectus fairly represents the opinion, limitations and work performed.
On this page9 sections
- Why expert work still needs sponsor review
- Select and assess the expert
- Understand inputs and assumptions
- Assess the report’s scope and work
- Verify facts and represent the opinion fairly
- Example: a site excluded from a technical study
- Example: market research and a changing definition
- Record and escalate expert issues
- Common errors in exam answers
- Sponsor is not the expert
- Assess the work without pretending to perform specialist analysis
- Expert checks
- Qualifications, experience, resources, independence and scope
- Report checks
- Factual basis, assumptions, limitations and consistency
- Sponsor duty
- Make reasonable inquiries and verify facts not checked by the expert
- Disclosure
- Fairly present the expert’s opinion and work
Why expert work still needs sponsor review
A listing applicant may need expert reports on matters such as property, mineral resources, environmental issues, market conditions or technical processes. The sponsor may not have the specialist qualifications to reproduce the expert’s analysis. That does not make the report a black box. The sponsor’s duty is to make reasonable inquiries, assess the expert and the work, and ensure that the listing document represents the opinion fairly.
The sponsor should understand what question the expert was asked, what information it used, what assumptions it made and what limitations apply. The inquiry is not “Do we agree with the expert’s professional conclusion?” in the abstract. It is whether the expert is competent and independent, whether the scope fits the opinion required, whether material facts and assumptions are reasonable and complete, and whether anything known to the sponsor calls the result into question.
HKEX Practice Note 21 gives examples of sponsor inquiries for expert sections. These include interviewing the expert, reviewing engagement terms and scope, considering qualifications and resources, reviewing factual information and assumptions, verifying facts the expert does not verify, and checking whether the prospectus fairly copies or extracts the report. The exact work depends on the applicant and expert subject. The note describes typical inquiries, not a universal formula.
Select and assess the expert
Begin with competence. Review qualifications, relevant experience, professional standing, available staff, technical tools and prior work in the relevant area. Experience in a neighboring field may not be enough if the assignment requires a distinct methodology. Ask who will perform and supervise the work, what quality controls apply and whether the expert can complete it within the transaction timetable. A firm name on the report does not tell you which individuals did the analysis or whether they had capacity.
Independence matters because the expert’s opinion can influence investor understanding. Consider financial, business, family or other relationships with the applicant, directors, controlling shareholders or sponsor group. Review the terms of engagement, fee arrangements and any prior work. A disclosed relationship is not automatically disqualifying, but it needs analysis. If independence is uncertain, obtain clarification and assess whether the report can be relied on, whether additional safeguards are required or whether another expert is needed.
Review engagement scope against the question in the prospectus. A report on the value of a property portfolio may not assess environmental liabilities or title. A market report may describe sector growth without testing the applicant’s market share. A technical assessment may examine a sample rather than every site. Read limitations and exclusions carefully. If the scope is too narrow to support the intended claim, either expand the work or narrow the claim.
Check resources and timing. An expert with excellent credentials may still be unable to complete a robust review if the team is too small, data arrive late or site access is restricted. Ask whether the expert had access to relevant records and personnel, whether any testing was omitted and how delays affected the conclusion. The sponsor should not assume that a concise report means the inquiry was exhaustive.
Understand inputs and assumptions
List the factual inputs on which the opinion depends. Identify the source, date, definition, scope and completeness of each input. If the expert uses management forecasts, sales data, site information or customer volumes, trace those inputs to supporting records or perform other proportionate checks. Ask whether the expert independently tested them. If not, the sponsor may need to verify the facts itself.
Assumptions should be visible and fair, reasonable and complete. Test whether an assumption fits the applicant’s history and current plans. If a valuation assumes full occupancy but the sponsor knows a major tenant left, investigate. If a market report assumes all announced projects will be completed, ask what approvals and financing exist. If a technical model excludes a site or product that contributes materially, understand why and whether the conclusion changes.
Consider sensitivity. A single central estimate can conceal substantial uncertainty. Ask which inputs have the greatest effect, what range is plausible and whether a modest change could alter the conclusion. The sponsor is not producing a new expert report, but it should understand whether the applicant’s narrative overstates certainty. Where the expert does not quantify sensitivity, the sponsor can still assess whether assumptions are unusually important and whether that limitation should be clear to readers.
Look for contradictions across workstreams. The expert may rely on one production volume while the audited accounts, operating data or management forecast show another. A property report may list a site as operational while diligence shows it is under renovation. A market study may define customers differently from the issuer’s sales ledger. Bring these differences to the expert and applicant, obtain a clear explanation and decide whether the report or prospectus must change.
Assess the report’s scope and work
Interview the expert about methodology, data sources, assumptions, procedures and limitations. The interview should focus on matters that affect the opinion and disclosure, not only biographical background. Ask what work was performed, how exceptions were handled, whether any requested information was unavailable and what the expert would not conclude. Record the answers, follow-up requests and how the sponsor evaluated them.
Read the report as a whole. Check the subject, period, units, definitions and intended use. Identify qualifications, disclaimers, reliance limitations, exclusions and date cut-offs. A report can be technically correct while not supporting the broader statement made in the summary or business section. Confirm that the prospectus uses the same meaning and does not remove a qualification that materially limits the conclusion.
If the expert revises its opinion, preserve the version history and understand why. A change may reflect new data, correction of an error or a different assumption. The sponsor should determine which other parts of the listing document rely on the prior version and update them consistently. Do not leave an old headline number in the summary after the body of the report has changed.
Where a limitation cannot be resolved, decide whether the opinion remains usable. Options may include a broader scope, additional evidence, a different expert, revised wording, an explicit limitation or withdrawal of the claim. The choice depends on materiality and whether the remaining disclosure allows investors to form a fair view. Simply inserting a generic disclaimer may not cure a central unsupported statement.
Verify facts and represent the opinion fairly
The sponsor should identify facts that the expert does not verify itself. For each material fact, decide whether it is supported by a reliable record, an independent source or additional inquiry. Verify the period and population: a report based on a sample needs clarity about how that sample relates to the full asset base. A public source should be current and authoritative; management data should be reconciled and tested according to risk.
The standard differs from the expert’s technical opinion. As a non-expert, the sponsor should make reasonable inquiries to be satisfied that it has no reasonable grounds to believe the information in the expert report is untrue, misleading or materially incomplete. This does not mean the sponsor guarantees the expert’s specialist conclusion. It does mean the sponsor must act on red flags and not ignore contradictions simply because they lie within a technical field.
Prospectus drafting should fairly describe the expert’s opinion and include a fair copy or extract of the relevant report. Check that the extract preserves context and qualifications. Ensure the listing document identifies the expert’s name, scope and material assumptions where required, and that other sections do not imply more certainty or broader coverage. Cross-check summary claims, risk factors, MD&A and expert sections for consistency.
A verification record should link the exact disclosure to the report or supporting source, note the procedures performed, identify reviewers, record exceptions and show resolution. If the expert report supports only a narrow claim, do not use it to verify a broader sentence. The record should make that scope boundary obvious to the drafter and reviewer.
Example: a site excluded from a technical study
Suppose an applicant operates five production sites. An expert assesses four, stating that the fifth is outside scope. The sponsor’s diligence suggests the excluded site contributes materially to output and management includes its production in the forecast. What is the appropriate response?
An expert assesses four of an applicant’s five sites. The excluded site contributes materially to output and appears in the forecast. What should the sponsor do?
- Accept the report because management approved the scope.
- Ask why the site was excluded, assess the effect on scope and assumptions, obtain proportionate further work and update the disclosure before relying on the report.
- Remove the site’s output from all records without investigation.
- State that four-site coverage is complete because most sites were inspected.
The sponsor might ask the expert to inspect the remaining site, review independent operating records, compare production data and explain whether the omission changes conclusions. It should assess the expert’s qualifications and resources for the added work, confirm assumptions and review the revised report. If the site cannot be evaluated, the prospectus must not imply that the expert’s opinion covers it. The forecast and risk disclosure may need separate treatment.
Example: market research and a changing definition
A market expert reports that the applicant is among the leading providers in a fast-growing sector. Its analysis defines the market to include only formal domestic sales and excludes imports and online channels. The issuer sells mainly through those excluded channels. The sponsor should ask whether the chosen market definition fits the applicant’s business and whether comparisons remain meaningful. If the headline claim changes under a broader definition, explain the basis or remove the ranking.
The team should test the report’s source data, period, assumptions and sampling. Interview the expert about exclusions and uncertainty. Compare the market estimate with public data and the applicant’s sales where definitions permit. Ensure that the prospectus states the applicable market, date and limitations. A confident “number one” statement is not supported if the comparator set leaves out major competitors.
Record and escalate expert issues
Keep the engagement letter, expert credentials, independence assessment, scope, assumptions, data map, interview notes, report versions, sponsor verification, comments and resolutions. Record what was not checked and why. If the sponsor relies on an expert’s work for an important statement, the file should show how it assessed the basis and why the limitation did not undermine disclosure.
Escalate promptly when the expert’s scope is inadequate, information is inconsistent, independence is doubtful or the report changes materially. The Principal should understand the issue and help determine resources and next steps. If the sponsor cannot reach a supportable conclusion, it should not sign a declaration merely because the expert signed its own report.
A post-issuance review can reveal whether the sponsor’s expert oversight was effective. Consider whether expert selections were appropriate, assumptions tested, limitations disclosed and concerns resolved. Use lessons to improve the firm’s expert engagement and review procedures. This is especially useful where the same type of expert work recurs across mandates.
Common errors in exam answers
Avoid saying “the sponsor must verify every expert conclusion itself.” That overstates the sponsor’s role and ignores specialist competence. The sponsor does need to assess the expert and make appropriate inquiries as a non-expert. Avoid the opposite extreme, “the expert is responsible, so the sponsor may rely without review.” The rules require sponsor judgement, and known contradictory information cannot be ignored.
Do not assume that a professional qualification proves the expert is suitable for every scope. Match experience and resources to the task. Do not assume independence because the expert was selected by the applicant. Examine relationships and engagement terms. Do not assume a report’s limitation is harmless just because it is disclosed somewhere. Assess its materiality and whether the prospectus’s overall impression remains fair.
Finally, connect the issue to disclosure. If an assumption is weak or data are incomplete, ask what the listing document says and whether the investor can understand the gap. A question may test the sponsor’s next step rather than demand a specialist answer. Focus on scope, evidence, fair presentation and escalation.
Scope example: a battery company claims a five year commercial advantage. The technical expert should identify which version and operating conditions were tested, whether data came from the company, what independent replication exists, which failures were excluded and whether the conclusion covers field durability. A controlled prototype test cannot automatically support a broad claim about commercial performance.
Assess independence beyond a declaration. Ask about prior work, fees linked to listing success, financial interests, director relationships and other assignments. A conflict may be manageable, but the sponsor must understand its effect, choose safeguards and record the rationale. A standard form does not replace an assessment of the actual relationship.
If the expert conclusion conflicts with internal testing or customer complaints, compare dates, scope, data and methodology. Ask the expert to address the difference and consider further work or narrower wording. If a material issue remains unresolved, escalate and reassess whether the sponsor can support the application.
Common questions
Must the sponsor redo the expert’s technical work?
Not necessarily. The sponsor should make reasonable inquiries as a non-expert, assess competence and scope, test material facts not verified by the expert and address contradictions.
How should a sponsor test an expert’s independence?
Review relationships, engagement terms, fee arrangements, prior work and other circumstances that could affect the expert’s judgement, then assess whether any issue can be managed.
What if the expert’s scope excludes a material site?
Ask why, assess how the exclusion affects assumptions and disclosure, obtain further work or narrow the claim, and escalate any unresolved material issue.
Can a prospectus quote only part of an expert report?
The excerpt should fairly represent the opinion and preserve material context, assumptions and limitations. It should not imply broader assurance than the full report provides.