Sitonce
Country: US
Show exams for United States Hong Kong
Sign in

IPO Due Diligence: HKSI Paper 15

Updated 13 min read
Key takeaway

Sponsor due diligence means making reasonable, risk-based inquiries to support the listing application and prospectus.

  • The sponsor must test material statements, investigate contradictions, assess expert work and verify disclosure.
  • Practice Note 21 describes typical inquiries, not a fixed checklist: each applicant’s risks determine the right scope and depth.
On this page10 sections
  1. What IPO due diligence is for
  2. Design a risk-based plan
  3. Apply professional scepticism
  4. Financial and operational inquiry
  5. Interview and corroborate
  6. Handle experts and third parties carefully
  7. Verification and disclosure
  8. MD&A and forecasts
  9. Worked case: resolve conflicting revenue evidence
  10. Records and closing issues
Purpose
Make reasonable inquiries to support sponsor declarations and listing disclosure
Standard
Risk-based; the suitable steps depend on the applicant and facts
Core attitude
Questioning mind, alert to contradictory evidence
Principal role
Set scope and resources, assess results, resolve issues
Primary references
Main Board Listing Rules, Practice Note 21, SFC Sponsor Provisions

What IPO due diligence is for

IPO due diligence is the sponsor’s process for learning the applicant well enough to support its regulatory responsibilities and the disclosures in the listing document. Chapter 3A of the Main Board Listing Rules requires reasonable inquiries, and Practice Note 21 describes typical inquiries. The note is not a fixed checklist: each applicant is different, so the sponsor must use judgement about which steps are needed and how far to pursue them. A small, uncomplicated business and a complex group with overseas operations do not call for identical work.

The purpose is not to collect a large folder or confirm that every document exists. The sponsor needs evidence that allows it to assess the applicant’s business, eligibility, financial condition, prospects, controls, directors and disclosure. It must look for information that undermines management’s explanations as well as information that supports them. If an important assertion cannot be supported, the team must resolve the gap, revise the disclosure or reconsider whether it can proceed.

A sound inquiry connects a statement to evidence and then to a conclusion. For example, “the company has a diversified customer base” needs a defined period, a customer-level analysis, a treatment of connected parties and a test of concentration. A management presentation repeating the phrase does not establish it. The sponsor may need sales ledgers, invoices, contracts, customer confirmations and collection records, reconciled to audited financial information. If these sources conflict, the conflict is the issue to resolve.

Design a risk-based plan

Begin with a map of the business: legal entities, ownership, products, markets, revenue channels, sites, key people, systems, material contracts and reliance on third parties. Understand how orders become revenue, how goods or services are delivered, how transactions are recorded and how cash is collected. This first map helps the team identify where management information comes from and where independent corroboration can be obtained. A business with a single key factory needs different site and continuity work from a software issuer with distributed delivery.

Identify the risk questions before choosing procedures. Is revenue recognized at the correct point? Are there related-party transactions? Does the issuer depend on a distributor or supplier? Are there pending claims or regulatory issues? Does the applicant meet the relevant listing requirements? Are forecasts consistent with historic performance and funding needs? These questions drive interviews, document requests, sampling, site visits and expert work. A procedure is useful only if it helps answer a relevant risk question.

The plan should record scope, workstream owners, milestones, evidence standards, Principal review points, exceptions and escalation routes. It should include dependencies: financial diligence may need to wait for updated accounts, while technical expert work may depend on finalized site data. The sponsor should revisit scope when new facts arise. An unexpected customer relationship, unexplained margin movement or missing licence can change both the inquiry and the timetable.

Resource planning is part of diligence. The sponsor should staff the engagement with people who understand the issuer’s sector, accounting, legal structure and relevant Hong Kong rules. If external advisers perform work, specify the question, scope, output and review process. Current SFC guidance emphasizes sufficient experienced staff and effective supervision. A deadline cannot justify compressing important work into a single late review.

Apply professional scepticism

Practice Note 21 describes professional scepticism as a critical assessment with a questioning mind and awareness of information, including expert information, that contradicts or calls reliability into question. It is not a presumption that management is dishonest. It means the sponsor does not treat a confident answer as proof. Ask what source supports the statement, who created that source, what could make it wrong and whether another record tells a different story.

Consider a company that reports unusually strong growth immediately before filing. Management attributes it to improved sales execution. The sponsor should test customer additions, order dates, delivery, acceptance, returns, invoice cut-off and cash receipts. Compare the explanation with product capacity and the customer’s own circumstances. If many new orders came from one connected distributor or were later cancelled, the original narrative may be incomplete. The sponsor should investigate the cause, assess any accounting or disclosure consequence and document its conclusion.

Scepticism matters when evidence is partly reliable. A contract may prove that a customer agreed to buy, but not that the goods were delivered or revenue properly recognized. A bank statement may corroborate a cash receipt, but not show whether the funds are refundable or linked to a side agreement. An expert’s opinion may be competent within its scope but based on assumptions that are inconsistent with other known facts. Ask what each item proves and what it leaves open.

Build contradictory evidence into the process. Team members should have a route to report concerns without first resolving them alone. The Principal and management should see significant issues, reputational risks and material changes. If evidence cannot be reconciled, preserve the different versions and the steps taken to resolve them. Editing out a concern from a summary before it reaches decision makers defeats the control.

Financial and operational inquiry

Financial diligence starts with audited financial statements but does not end there. Reconcile material numbers to ledgers and supporting records. Understand the accounting policies, audit qualifications, consolidation perimeter, changes in estimates, tax position, working capital, borrowings and commitments. Compare financial performance across periods and ask what drove each material change. The sponsor should test whether explanations fit operational data such as units sold, pricing, capacity, headcount or customer mix.

Working capital deserves a forward view. A company can report earnings while cash is tied up in receivables or inventory. Examine collection patterns, overdue balances, inventory ageing, supplier terms and seasonality. Compare forecast assumptions with historical conversion and the latest trading information. If management expects a sharp improvement, identify the operational actions that produce it and test whether those actions are already underway. A liquidity statement should fit obligations and cash-flow timing, not just a year-end balance.

Operational inquiry tests whether the business described in the prospectus can actually produce the reported outcome. Site visits, process walkthroughs, staff interviews and third-party confirmations can test systems and controls. If revenue depends on a platform, inspect how data are generated and access is controlled. If a manufacturer relies on one production line, investigate capacity, downtime, maintenance and alternative supply. If services are delivered by subcontractors, test contract terms, quality controls and the issuer’s ability to monitor performance.

Legal and compliance diligence should identify licences, litigation, material contracts, intellectual property rights, environmental and safety matters where relevant, and compliance history. The sponsor does not replace lawyers, but should understand material findings and ensure they are reflected accurately. A specialist’s report that identifies a limitation should lead to questions about its business impact and disclosure, not just a file note that legal review occurred.

Interview and corroborate

Interviews are most useful when they test a defined hypothesis and generate follow-up evidence. Speak with senior management, finance, operations and other staff who understand the process. Where appropriate, the inquiry may extend to customers, suppliers, bankers and other counterparties. Ask open questions first, then test specific inconsistencies. Record who participated, the subject, key explanations, documents promised and whether independent information corroborated the account. A meeting memory is not a substitute for a contemporaneous record.

When interviewing a customer, avoid leading questions that simply invite confirmation of management’s narrative. Ask about the relationship, products or services, order process, delivery, returns, payment terms, disputes and future plans. Consider whether the contact is independent and has authority to speak. Compare the response with the contract and the issuer’s records. If a customer declines to respond, document that fact and consider other corroboration rather than treating silence as confirmation.

Site visits should be tailored to what the sponsor needs to understand. Observe the process, inspect material assets, ask staff to explain controls and compare physical reality with the description in the listing document. A visit alone does not establish capacity or ownership; supporting records may be needed. If facilities are leased, outsourced or shared, clarify the applicant’s rights and operational dependence. Record limitations, including parts of the site or process that were not observed.

Handle experts and third parties carefully

Experts supply technical work that the sponsor may not be qualified to perform, but reliance requires active assessment. Consider qualifications, experience, resources, independence, engagement terms, scope, assumptions and data sources. Ask whether the scope fits the opinion required and whether limitations affect the assurance. Review the listing document’s expert section for accurate description of factual inputs, assumptions and work performed. The sponsor should verify material underlying facts that the expert does not verify itself, to the standard reasonably expected of a non-expert sponsor.

Where an expert relies on applicant-provided data, the sponsor should identify the data owner, source system, period, definitions and reconciliation. A valuation, market study or technical report can be wrong if the input population is incomplete or the assumptions are not reasonable. If the sponsor knows that a major site, product line or liability is omitted, it should ask why and consider whether the report and disclosure remain fair. Do not simply state that the expert is responsible for everything in its section.

Other third parties also need scrutiny. A service provider may handle application forms, data processing or specialist procedures. Understand its experience, scope and controls, and how its work will be reviewed. Outsourcing a task does not outsource the sponsor’s responsibility to make its own required inquiries. If the work product is incomplete or inconsistent, obtain clarification and additional evidence before relying on it.

Verification and disclosure

Verification links a material statement in the listing document to reliable support. Use a verification record that contains the exact sentence, the source, the procedure performed, the reviewer, exceptions and resolution. A public statistic should be traced to a current authoritative source and its period and definition checked. A financial statement should be tied to the corresponding audited figure or clearly identified as an adjustment. A claim about market ranking needs a defined market, comparable set and methodology.

The sponsor must check context, not just individual facts. A prospectus can contain accurate numbers that create a misleading impression when a trend, definition or limitation is omitted. Make sure statements agree across the summary, business, industry, MD&A, risk factors and expert reports. Verify that the stated period, currency, entity and basis are consistent. If a number is rounded or adjusted, explain the method where needed. If later information changes the context, update the disclosure and reopen verification.

The listing document should enable an informed reader to assess the applicant and its securities. The sponsor should compare the draft with requirements in the Listing Rules and current guidance, while ensuring the story remains coherent and not overloaded. Material risk factors should be specific to the applicant, explain the mechanism of potential harm and be consistent with the rest of the document. Generic boilerplate cannot cure the omission of an important known issue.

MD&A and forecasts

MD&A connects the financial statements with the business. It should explain material period-on-period changes in revenue, costs, margins, assets, liabilities and cash flow, using drivers supported by evidence. If sales increased because of a one-off customer order, say so and explain whether it is recurring. If margins changed due to product mix, quantify the contribution where possible. If a line item is volatile, explain the business cause rather than merely restating the movement.

Forecasts and projections need a reasonable basis. Compare budgets with historical sales, payment terms, costs, financing, long-term liabilities and working-capital needs. Interview management about assumptions and test them against external and internal evidence. If growth assumes new capacity, ask whether capital expenditure, approvals, staff and supply are available. If a forecast assumes a customer renewal, inspect the contract or obtain confirmation. A scenario should also consider the effect of slower sales, delayed collection or cost inflation where material.

When there is a limitation in available information, identify it and assess its importance. Do not replace an uncertain estimate with unsupported precision. The sponsor must be satisfied that the wording fairly describes the basis and assumptions. If the underlying record does not support the forecast narrative, amend the forecast, explain the uncertainty or escalate whether the application can continue.

Worked case: resolve conflicting revenue evidence

An applicant says its new distributor generated a large year-end order. The contract exists and an invoice was issued, but the goods were delivered after year end, the distributor paid only a small deposit and later requested a return right not shown in the contract. What should the sponsor investigate?

Worked case

A year-end distributor order is supported by a contract and invoice, but delivery occurred later, only a deposit was paid and a return request surfaced. What is the strongest sponsor response?

  1. Accept revenue because the signed contract is enough.
  2. Investigate delivery, acceptance, payment, return rights and any side agreement; assess accounting and prospectus disclosure before relying on the revenue claim.
  3. Ignore the return request because it came after year end.
  4. Ask management to repeat its explanation in writing and close the issue.
Answer: B. The evidence raises questions about cut-off, transfer of control, collectability and undisclosed terms. The sponsor should obtain corroborating records and assess the accounting and disclosure effect. A contract and invoice alone do not establish that the revenue claim is properly supported. A written repeat of management’s explanation is not independent corroboration.

A complete inquiry might inspect delivery notes, customer correspondence, subsequent credit notes, cash receipts, relevant accounting policies, return rights and comparable transactions. It should establish whether the side request changes the original deal or reveals a broader practice. Then consider the effect on reported revenue, forecasts, customer concentration and internal controls. Document the result and escalate it to the Principal and relevant committee if material.

Records and closing issues

Keep a file that reconstructs how the sponsor reached its conclusion. It should include the due-diligence plan, requests, interview notes, source records, analyses, exceptions, review comments, decisions and final resolution. Retain significant internal discussions and actions, not only polished final memoranda. If a regulator later asks why a statement was included, the sponsor should be able to locate its support and explain the reasoning.

Before submission, revisit each open issue and ask whether it has an owner, evidence, resolution and disclosure consequence. “Pending” should not disappear because the timetable is tight. Some issues may be resolved by obtaining evidence; others require qualification, correction or escalation. A sponsor should be prepared to delay filing if it cannot complete essential work. Good project management makes this decision visible early enough to preserve alternatives.

Due diligence continues as facts change. New financial results, acquisitions, customer losses, litigation, management departures or regulatory developments can make prior checks stale. Monitor key statements up to issuance and check whether the sponsor’s declarations remain supportable. Record the date and scope of update work. A verification record from months earlier does not establish that a new prospectus draft remains accurate.

Common questions

Is Practice Note 21 a fixed checklist?

No. It describes typical Main Board inquiries, while the scope and depth appropriate for a particular applicant depend on its facts and risks.

Can a sponsor rely entirely on an expert report?

No. The sponsor should assess the expert, scope, assumptions, factual basis and fair presentation, and investigate contradictions it knows about.

What is professional scepticism in sponsor due diligence?

It is a questioning, critical assessment that stays alert to information contradicting or undermining management statements and other evidence.

What should a verification record contain?

It should identify the exact disclosure, supporting source, work performed, reviewer, exceptions and how each exception was resolved.