Basis Risk: HKSI Paper 9
Basis risk is the uncertainty that a futures price and the cash exposure being hedged will not move together by the same amount.
- Differences in underlying, grade, location, maturity or hedge timing can leave a residual gain or loss.
- A hedge can reduce risk without eliminating it.
On this page8 sections
What basis means
Basis is commonly spot price minus futures price, although a question can define it differently. Always follow the convention in the stem. Basis changes when spot and futures move by different amounts. A hedger who closes before the futures contract expires is exposed to that movement. At expiry, futures and the deliverable or settlement reference usually converge according to contract terms, but a cash exposure that differs from the futures underlying may still be mismatched.
A futures hedge can therefore be effective in direction and imperfect in amount. The cash price may rise while the futures price rises less. A long futures hedge offsets only part of the increased cash cost. Basis risk is the residual uncertainty from the relationship between the actual exposure and hedge instrument, not simply “the future price went down.”
Sources of basis risk
The hedge asset may differ from the contract’s underlying. A company buying one grade of a commodity may hedge with a related but not identical grade. A manufacturer may face a location-specific cash price while the exchange future references a broader benchmark. A portfolio’s composition may not track the index exactly. Each mismatch can cause spot and futures returns to diverge.
Timing also matters. If the exposure occurs in a month without a matching contract, the hedger may use a nearby expiry and roll it. The cash price and chosen contract can change at different rates while the hedge is held, and the roll may occur at an adverse spread. A hedge that is closed early leaves the prevailing basis unresolved. Use a maturity matched to the exposure when possible, but recognize that matching dates does not remove every source of mismatch.
Worked basis example
Assume a processor’s cash input price rises from 100 to 108, while the related futures price rises from 102 to 107. The processor buys futures as a hedge against rising input cost. The cash cost increases by 8 units, while the futures position gains 5 units before contract-size adjustment. The net exposure worsens by 3 units per matched quantity, ignoring costs. The futures hedge helped, but a 3-unit residual remains because the two prices did not move equally.
Using basis = spot minus futures, initial basis is 100 − 102 = −2. Later basis is 108 − 107 = 1. Basis widened by 3, which corresponds to the residual shortfall in this simplified long hedge setup. If the stem uses futures minus spot, the sign reverses, so state the convention before interpreting “strengthened” or “weakened.” The arithmetic shows why basis can matter more than the standalone direction of futures.
Cross hedging and hedge ratio
A cross hedge uses a futures contract on a related asset when no directly matching contract is available. The correlation between cash exposure and futures returns is less than perfect, so the hedge ratio is estimated and can change. A theoretical minimum-variance hedge ratio is related to correlation and relative volatility, but only use a formula if the question provides the required inputs and assumptions.
A one-to-one number of contracts is not automatically the right hedge. Contract size, exposure quantity, price sensitivity and expected covariance matter. If the hedge is too small, substantial exposure remains; if too large, the position can become speculative. The syllabus’s risk-management framing makes this distinction important: hedging is a process of choosing an offset, monitoring residual risk and adjusting when the exposure or relationship changes.
Managing rather than denying basis risk
Choose a contract whose underlying and delivery or settlement terms are close to the exposure. Match maturity where practical and use a documented hedge ratio. Monitor both prices and the basis, not only the futures P/L. If the hedge is rolled, calculate the new basis and the cost of changing contract months. Keep records of the objective and the remaining mismatch so the hedge is not mistaken for a profit strategy.
No instrument can remove risks it does not reference. An equity-index future can hedge broad market beta but not company-specific news. An interest-rate swap can change benchmark-rate exposure but not necessarily a borrower’s credit spread. A currency forward can lock a rate yet leave the amount or date uncertain if the underlying transaction changes. A realistic hedge description states the risk mitigated and the risk left behind.
How basis risk appears in questions
A stem may describe a cash price and a futures price changing by different amounts, then ask about hedge effectiveness. Calculate the cash exposure and futures position separately before netting. Another question may define basis and ask whether it strengthened; write the definition and compute both dates. A third may present a cross hedge and ask why it is imperfect; point to correlation, contract mismatch or timing, not generic “market volatility.”
Avoid two shortcuts. First, do not equate a gain on the futures with a successful hedge if the underlying exposure is unspecified. Second, do not infer basis risk solely from the fact that the position is closed before expiry; it is the uncertain price relationship that matters. Read whether the hedge is long or short, whether the exposure is a cost or asset, and which basis convention is in use.
A closer worked application
A cross hedge requires more than noticing that two prices are correlated. Choose a contract linked to the exposure, estimate how their price changes relate, account for each contract’s size and set a hedge ratio. The minimum-variance ratio uses covariance and futures variance in a simple model, but the relationship can change over time. If the question supplies a ratio, use it. If it asks conceptually, explain why imperfect correlation leaves residual movement instead of inventing a numeric hedge count.
A hedge can become mismatched as the business exposure changes. A shipment can be delayed, a production quantity revised or a portfolio’s composition drift from an index. Leaving the original futures position unchanged may turn part of the hedge into an unplanned directional position. Monitoring therefore includes both the underlying exposure and the hedge instrument. Rebalancing can reduce mismatch but adds transaction costs and can realize losses. Risk management is an ongoing decision, not a one-time contract choice.
A second check that strengthens recall
Basis direction can be confusing because two common definitions reverse the sign. If basis is spot minus futures, a rise in basis means spot has strengthened relative to futures. If basis is futures minus spot, the same market move gives the opposite numerical sign. The hedging consequence depends on the exposure and position. Write the convention explicitly, calculate both dates and interpret which price has moved more before describing the hedge as stronger or weaker.
A minimum-variance hedge ratio is useful when the hedge instrument is related but not identical to the cash exposure. It accounts for relative volatility and correlation rather than assuming one contract offsets one unit. In a real decision, estimates are based on data and can break when market relationships change. The exam may give a formula or ratio; apply only the inputs provided. Conceptually, lower correlation or more unstable basis means less reliable offset and greater residual risk.
Common questions
Does basis risk mean the hedge failed?
No. The hedge may reduce the exposure while leaving a residual because cash and futures prices moved by different amounts..
What is the usual basis formula?
A common convention is spot price minus futures price, but follow the definition given by the question or contract context..
Can basis risk be eliminated?
A closely matched contract and maturity can reduce it, but differences in underlying, timing, location or hedge ratio may remain..
What is a cross hedge?
It uses a related futures contract to hedge an exposure without an exact matching contract, leaving risk if the two prices do not move together..