Futures and Forward Contracts: HKSI Paper 9
Forwards and futures both set terms for a transaction at a later date, but their market structure and risk controls differ.
- A forward is typically a privately negotiated OTC agreement; a future is standardized and exchange traded, with clearing and margin processes.
- Both create linear exposure, so direction and contract terms drive the result.
On this page7 sections
The shared economic idea
A forward or future fixes an agreed price for a later transaction or cash settlement. One side benefits when the market price moves in its favour and the other loses by the corresponding amount, subject to contract terms. A buyer of a future is commonly described as long; the seller is short. At the time the agreement is made, neither side has the option buyer’s one-sided right. Each side is committed under the contract.
For a simple forward without income or storage considerations, the no-arbitrage price is related to the spot price and financing over the term. A textbook continuous-compounding illustration is F0 = S0 × e^(rT), assuming a known risk-free rate, no distributions or costs and continuous compounding. The formula is an educational simplification. Real products can require dividends, funding curves, collateral, convenience yield, foreign rates or other terms. Follow the assumptions in a question.
How a forward differs from a future
A forward is commonly negotiated bilaterally between counterparties. Its notional, maturity and other terms can be tailored, which can make it fit a hedge closely. The trade is also exposed to the counterparty and documentation arrangements unless mitigated by collateral or clearing. A future is standardized by an exchange. The clearing house steps into the clearing relationship, and the contract is typically marked to market through margin arrangements. Standardization improves transferability but can create a hedge mismatch.
Think of an importer that needs a currency amount on a specific date. A tailor-made forward can match the amount and date more closely. A listed currency future may be available only in standard size and expiry months, so the hedge may need rounding or closing before maturity. That mismatch is not proof that futures are unsuitable; it is a source of basis and rollover risk to quantify. In an exam stem, focus on which feature the question asks you to compare.
Worked futures P/L
Assume one HSI future is bought at 20,100 and later settled at 20,060. HKEX’s current product page states the standard multiplier is HKD 50 per index point. The move is minus 40 points, so gross P/L for the long is −40 × HKD 50 = a HKD 2,000 loss, before fees and other cash flows. A short position would have the equal positive gross result for that price move.
The arithmetic starts with change, not level. Multiplying 20,060 by 50 would be a contract value calculation of a different kind, not the P/L. If there were three contracts, multiply the per-contract result by three. If the question used a mini future, check the mini multiplier. Contract facts can change, so the HKEX product page is the source for current specification and the HKSI guide defines the exam scope.
Margins, clearing and credit exposure
A futures position generally requires margin, but the deposit is not the contract price and does not limit loss. Initial margin supports the clearing process against potential future exposure. Variation margin transfers gains and losses as the contract is revalued. If losses reduce available funds below required levels, the broker or clearing arrangement may require more collateral or close positions under its rules. Requirements can differ between clearing house and client.
A forward may instead be collateralized under a bilateral agreement or cleared if eligible and accepted. Its credit exposure depends on the contract’s value, netting, collateral and counterparty credit. Neither product is free of operational or liquidity risk. When comparing them, avoid a categorical statement that futures eliminate risk or that forwards are always more dangerous. Identify the risk, control and trade-off in the specific scenario.
Hedging and basis
A futures hedge uses a standardized contract to offset a cash-market exposure. Basis is often defined as spot price minus futures price, though a question may state a different convention. If spot and futures do not move in lockstep, the hedge result is imperfect. Contract month, underlying grade or asset, location, timing and hedge ratio can all matter. A close-out before expiry leaves basis movement as a source of uncertainty.
A wheat processor exposed to rising input prices may buy a related futures contract. If the cash wheat price rises by more than the future, the futures gain does not fully offset the input cost. If the relationship moves the other way, the hedge may overcompensate. The contract can still reduce risk compared with remaining entirely exposed. The point is to measure residual risk, not demand a perfect one-for-one offset where the instruments differ.
How to answer a comparison question
First name the contract structure: negotiated OTC forward or standardized exchange future. Next identify how settlement, clearing and margin work in the described case. Then assess custom fit, liquidity, credit exposure, basis, transaction costs and operational needs only to the extent the stem asks. A forward’s custom terms can improve matching; a future’s standardization and clearing can aid trading and risk management. These are tendencies, not guarantees of lower total cost or risk.
A strong answer avoids absolute language. “All futures are risk-free because of clearing” is false; margin calls and market losses remain. “Every forward settles only at maturity” is too broad because collateral and interim payments can be contractually specified. “Futures are always more liquid” depends on contract and market. Precision matters more than memorising a single pro/con list.
A closer worked application
For a simple long future, a rising settlement price creates a gain and a falling price creates a loss, with variation amounts reflecting the change between marks. A forward’s value changes as the underlying and relevant financing terms move, but interim cash flows depend on the agreement and collateral terms. Therefore, do not answer “futures settle daily, forwards settle only at maturity” as an absolute. State the usual structure, then acknowledge that real bilateral agreements may provide collateral and interim payments.
Common questions
Are forwards and futures both derivatives?
Yes. Both are contracts whose value is linked to an underlying reference, and both can create linear long or short exposure..
Which has more customizable terms?
A bilateral forward can commonly be tailored to amount and maturity. Futures use standardized exchange specifications, which can produce hedge mismatch..
Does margin cap futures losses?
No. Margin supports performance and daily risk control; it does not cap market loss. A position can require additional funds..
What does basis risk mean in a futures hedge?
It is the uncertainty from imperfect movement between the cash exposure and the futures contract, including differences in underlying, timing or contract month..