Sitonce
Country: US
Show exams for United States Hong Kong
Sign in

Patent Obviousness: Patent Bar

Updated 3 min read
Key takeaway

Obviousness asks whether the claimed subject matter as a whole would have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in view of the prior art and relevant evidence.

  • Identifying every element somewhere is not enough.
  • Explain why a skilled person would combine or modify teachings, avoid hindsight, and consider objective indicia.
On this page8 sections
  1. Build the analysis in order
  2. Avoid hindsight reconstruction
  3. Teaching-suggestion-motivation is not a rigid checklist
  4. Objective evidence
  5. A simple original example
  6. Reasonable expectation of success
  7. Skill level is factual context
  8. Handle objective evidence
Current source date
USPTO update September 23, 2026
Format
100 questions; 90 scored; 360 minutes
Passing rule
63 of 90 scored questions

Build the analysis in order

Identify the relevant prior art, construe the claim, determine differences, and assess the level of ordinary skill. Then explain whether the claimed subject matter would have been obvious in that context, including a reasoned basis for any combination or modification. The claim is evaluated as a whole.

Do not stop at saying every component appears somewhere. A combination needs an explanation supported by the record and technical reasoning.

Avoid hindsight reconstruction

The claim itself cannot be the roadmap that makes separate references seem naturally combinable. State the reason a skilled person would have made the proposed change at the relevant time. That reason may come from the references, common knowledge supported by evidence, design incentives, or another articulated rationale.

A successful result can look simple after the invention is known. Reconstruct the perspective without using the claim as a template.

Teaching-suggestion-motivation is not a rigid checklist

A teaching, suggestion, or motivation can support a rationale, but the analysis is not limited to an express sentence in the reference telling the reader to combine. Apply the current flexible obviousness framework and give a supported explanation.

Do not overcorrect by claiming that any combination is permitted. The reason still must be articulated and grounded in evidence or ordinary skill.

Objective evidence

Commercial success, long-felt but unresolved need, failure of others, and other objective evidence may be relevant when properly connected to the claimed invention. The evidence should be considered with the full record, not dismissed simply because the prior art appears close.

A nexus between the evidence and the claimed features can matter. Avoid treating sales alone as conclusive or ignoring evidence because it arises after filing.

A simple original example

A first reference shows a container and removable lid; a second shows a locking tab. For obviousness, explain whether a skilled artisan had a reason to add the tab to the container and whether the modification would have had a reasonable expectation of success. The references’ mere existence does not complete the analysis.

This differs from anticipation, where one reference ordinarily must disclose each limitation in the claimed arrangement.

Reasonable expectation of success

A motivation to try a combination does not always establish a reasonable expectation that it will work. Consider the predictability of the field, compatibility of components, and technical obstacles identified in the record. The inquiry is not a guarantee of success, but it must be more than unsupported speculation.

Explain what a skilled person would have expected based on the art and ordinary knowledge. Avoid importing the applicant’s later success into the analysis.

Skill level is factual context

The person of ordinary skill is a legal construct whose level can affect what combinations or substitutions would have been routine. Consider the field, problems encountered, prior solutions, and sophistication of the technology as the record supports.

Do not define skill after reading the claim in a way that guarantees the desired result.

Handle objective evidence

Consider commercial success, long-felt need, failure of others, or other evidence when properly supported and linked to the claimed features. A product’s popularity alone does not establish nexus.

Common questions

What is obviousness?

Whether the claimed subject matter as a whole would have been obvious to ordinary skill.

Must a reference say “combine”?

No, but the rationale must be articulated and supported.

Is finding each element enough?

No. Explain the reasoned combination and consider objective evidence.

What is hindsight?

Using knowledge of the claim to reconstruct the path without proper basis.