Constitutional Amendments: Praxis Citizenship Education: Content Knowledge 5087
Article V provides two ways to propose a constitutional amendment and two ways to ratify it.
- Congress can propose by a two-thirds vote in each chamber, or Congress must call a proposing convention after applications from two-thirds of state legislatures.
- Ratification requires three-fourths of states through the mode Congress specifies.
On this page8 sections
- What does Article V require?
- How does the congressional proposal route work?
- How does the convention proposal route work?
- How is an amendment ratified?
- How do the thresholds work in a 50-state example?
- Why is the amendment process different from ordinary lawmaking?
- A fictional classroom example
- How to answer an Article V test question
What does Article V require?
Article V sets out the constitutional amendment process. It distinguishes proposal from ratification. An amendment can be proposed by Congress when two-thirds of both houses deem it necessary, or Congress must call a convention for proposing amendments on applications from two-thirds of the state legislatures. In either case, ratification follows through legislatures or conventions in three-fourths of the states, as Congress may propose.
The process is more demanding than passing an ordinary federal statute because it requires specified supermajorities across national or state institutions. A proposed amendment is not already part of the Constitution. It must be ratified by the required share of states. Do not confuse introduction, congressional proposal, state consideration, ratification and official certification.
- Proposal route 1
- Two-thirds vote in each house of Congress
- Proposal route 2
- Applications from two-thirds of state legislatures require Congress to call a proposing convention
- Ratification
- Three-fourths of states
- Ratification mode
- State legislatures or state conventions, as Congress specifies
- Presidential signature
- Not part of Article V proposal process
- U.S. thresholds for 50 states
- At least 34 state applications; 38 ratifications
How does the congressional proposal route work?
Congress may propose an amendment when two-thirds of both the House of Representatives and the Senate deem it necessary. Each chamber has its own denominator. It is not enough to add all members together and calculate two-thirds of the combined total. The two houses act as separate constitutional bodies.
The National Archives explains that Congress proposes an amendment as a joint resolution. Because the President has no constitutional role in this amendment proposal process, the resolution does not go to the White House for signature or approval. This distinguishes proposing a constitutional amendment from an ordinary bill presented to the President.
After proposal, the amendment goes to the states for consideration. Congress specifies whether ratification is by state legislatures or state conventions. The proposal step and the ratification step involve different institutions and thresholds. A proposal vote in Congress does not itself change the Constitution.
How does the convention proposal route work?
Article V also provides a route initiated by applications from two-thirds of state legislatures. Once the threshold is met, Congress must call a convention for proposing amendments. This is a convention for proposing amendments, not itself the state ratification stage. The proposed amendment would still need ratification by three-fourths of the states through the mode Congress specifies.
The National Archives notes that none of the 27 amendments had been proposed through a convention as of its published explanatory material. That historical statement should not be turned into a prediction about future proposals. It also does not settle contemporary disputes about how applications, rescissions, subject matching or deadlines would be treated. Those issues require current legal authority beyond a basic study summary.
When reading an Article V question, identify what has happened: state applications, a convention call, proposal language, state votes or certification. A statement that enough legislatures applied does not mean a proposed amendment has been ratified. A statement that Congress has proposed an amendment does not mean it has been adopted.
How is an amendment ratified?
Ratification requires approval in three-fourths of the states. Article V allows ratification by state legislatures or state conventions, with Congress specifying which mode applies to a given proposal. This is not a national popular referendum. A nationwide majority vote cannot substitute for the constitutional state threshold described in Article V.
With 50 states, three-fourths is 37.5. Because a fraction of a state cannot ratify, at least 38 states are required to reach or exceed the threshold. This is a whole-number threshold calculation. It does not mean the state votes are weighted by population.
The National Archives administers the current recordkeeping and certification process after state actions are received. Its explanation describes checking ratification documents and certifying when the required number is reached. Separate the constitutional ratification condition from later administrative verification and preservation of records.
| Stage | Threshold or action | Common mistake |
|---|---|---|
| Congressional proposal | Two-thirds in House and two-thirds in Senate | Combine both chambers into one vote denominator |
| Convention trigger | Applications from two-thirds of state legislatures | Treat applications as ratification |
| Ratification | Three-fourths of states by specified mode | Use a national popular-vote majority |
| Certification | Official confirmation after required ratifications | Confuse recordkeeping with the proposal vote |
How do the thresholds work in a 50-state example?
Two-thirds of 50 equals 33⅓. At least 34 whole state legislatures must apply to reach the convention trigger. Three-fourths of 50 equals 37.5, so 38 states must ratify. These are state counts. Do not round down because the threshold must be met or exceeded.
For Congress, do not use 50 as a denominator. The Constitution says two-thirds of both houses. In a simplified arithmetic exercise, first identify each chamber’s membership or the voting denominator specified in the question, then compute two-thirds separately. A question may state whether the denominator is all members or members present; use the facts supplied rather than assuming a procedure that is not described.
This arithmetic is useful for distinguishing stages, but it does not answer whether any particular proposed amendment has met a real-world threshold. Current controversies over historic state actions require case-specific legal research. Avoid inferring a current status from a classroom example or old explanatory summary.
Why is the amendment process different from ordinary lawmaking?
Ordinary federal legislation proceeds through Congress and the presentment process described in the Constitution. Article V instead requires proposal through a supermajority route and ratification by states. The President does not sign a congressional proposal under the described Article V procedure. The higher thresholds create a distinct mechanism for altering the constitutional text.
An amendment can add, modify or repeal constitutional provisions. The National Archives transcript links amendments with the constitutional text, so read provisions as amended rather than relying only on original wording. For example, a question about the current selection of senators should account for the Seventeenth Amendment, not present the original legislative-selection clause as current practice.
Article V also contains limitations. It includes a temporary restriction concerning specified clauses before 1808, and it protects a state from losing equal suffrage in the Senate without that state’s consent. Read the exact text if a question asks about these qualifications. Do not reduce Article V to only the two-thirds and three-fourths fractions.
A fictional classroom example
Suppose 35 state legislatures submit applications seeking a convention to propose an amendment. In a 50-state model, the two-thirds application threshold is 34, so the applications exceed that trigger. This does not mean an amendment has been proposed or ratified. The scenario has reached the convention-call stage described in Article V, subject to the legal treatment of the applications.
Suppose a separate congressional proposal later receives ratification from 37 states. Three-fourths of 50 is 37.5, so 37 is not enough; the threshold is 38. If one more state ratifies, the arithmetic reaches the threshold. Whether particular records count in a real controversy is a separate legal question, not answered by the arithmetic alone.
How to answer an Article V test question
Underline the action verb and institution. Is the question asking who can propose, what triggers a convention, which mode ratifies, or how many states meet a fraction? Label the stage before calculating. Then use the correct denominator and round a state count upward when needed.
If a question asks whether a proposed amendment is part of the Constitution, check whether the ratification threshold has been met. Do not stop at congressional approval. If the question asks about presidential participation, distinguish ordinary legislation from Article V proposal. If it asks about a current dispute, use any supplied legal source and avoid importing unsupported conclusions.
Primary text provides the rule; an explanatory page can clarify administrative steps. The National Archives Article V page reproduces the constitutional language, while its amendment-process page summarizes how ratification records are processed. The latter was last reviewed years ago and cautions that process details are not fully specified in Article V. Use it for the basic pathway, not to settle current disputes over rescission, deadlines or contested ratification histories.
Article V sets two proposal routes and two ratification modes. Proposal requires two-thirds in both congressional houses or applications from two-thirds of state legislatures for a convention. Ratification requires three-fourths of states by the mode Congress specifies.
Common questions
How many states must ratify an amendment?
Three-fourths of states must ratify. With 50 states, at least 38 are needed because three-fourths equals 37.5 and the threshold must be met with a whole number of states.
Does the President sign a constitutional amendment?
The President has no constitutional role in the Article V congressional proposal process described by the National Archives. The proposed amendment goes through state ratification rather than ordinary bill presentment.
What is the convention route?
Applications from two-thirds of state legislatures require Congress to call a convention for proposing amendments. Any proposal still requires ratification by three-fourths of states through the mode Congress specifies.
Does Congress propose an amendment with one combined two-thirds vote?
No. Article V requires two-thirds of both houses. Each chamber is considered separately; the threshold is not two-thirds of the combined House and Senate membership.