Formative and Summative Assessment: Praxis Elementary Education: Curriculum, Instruction, and Assessment 5017
Formative assessment gathers evidence during learning so a teacher can adjust instruction and give feedback; summative assessment evaluates learning after a defined period or unit.
- The distinction depends on purpose and use, not the quiz format alone.
- For Praxis 5017, connect each assessment choice to a learning objective, interpret the student evidence, and select a next teaching step.
On this page10 sections
- The purpose determines how an assessment is used
- Start with the learning objective and success criteria
- Use formative checks to make an instructional decision
- Recognize misconceptions from the pattern of errors
- Summative assessment reports learning at a defined point
- Choose among observation, traditional and standardized measures
- Use reliability, validity and fairness as practical checks
- Combine evidence without overclaiming
- Original Praxis-style assessment questions
- Fit assessment knowledge to Praxis 5017
The purpose determines how an assessment is used
An assessment is formative when a teacher and learner use evidence during instruction to decide what to do next. The teacher may clarify a misconception, change a model, provide a targeted prompt or extend a student’s thinking. A summative assessment evaluates learning at the end of a defined interval, such as a unit, project or term. It may contribute to a grade or report. The distinction is functional: the same short quiz can be formative if its results guide the next lesson, or summative if it is used only to evaluate an endpoint.
In Praxis 5017, assessment belongs within a larger picture of curriculum, instruction and assessment. The code-specific Study Companion expects beginning teachers to know how to design and use formative assessments to adjust instruction; design, use and interpret summative assessments; recognize misconceptions and reteach; and select suitable methods, including observations, traditional assessments and standardized assessments. A strong response does not stop at naming a tool. It identifies the learning goal, the evidence collected, what the evidence means and how the teacher will respond.
| Question | Formative use | Summative use |
|---|---|---|
| When? | During instruction or while learning can still change | At the end of a defined unit, period or performance |
| Why? | Find current understanding and decide the next teaching move | Judge or report what learners demonstrated against criteria |
| What follows? | Feedback, adjustment, reteaching, practice or extension | A grade, summary, placement decision or record, depending on policy |
| Example | A hinge question before introducing unlike denominators | A unit task requiring students to compare and operate on fractions |
Start with the learning objective and success criteria
A useful assessment begins with a precise objective. “Understand fractions” is too broad to guide evidence collection. “Place one-half, three-fourths and five-eighths on a number line from zero to one and justify their order” describes an observable performance. The teacher can then identify what counts as successful evidence: correct placement, a consistent unit interval and an explanation that connects equivalent fractions or benchmark reasoning to the positions.
Success criteria make the target visible before students work. Criteria should describe the quality of the response, not simply the activity. “Complete the worksheet” describes task completion; “use a common whole and explain why the numerator alone does not determine fraction size” describes the intended understanding. Criteria can be shared as a checklist, model or brief rubric. For young learners, plain language and a concrete example can make expectations easier to use.
Align the evidence to the objective. If the goal is oral explanation, a silent multiple-choice quiz may provide useful recognition data but little evidence of speaking or reasoning. If the goal is to identify a main idea in a short passage, a broad report about reading level may be too indirect. Ask what the student must know or do, then choose an evidence source that allows that performance to be observed with reasonable clarity.
A teacher can plan backward with four linked prompts: What should students learn? What would show that they learned it? What instructional experiences will help them reach it? What response will follow different patterns in the evidence? Planning the response matters because formative assessment is not just frequent testing. If a teacher collects exit tickets and never examines them or changes instruction, the evidence has not completed a formative cycle.
Use formative checks to make an instructional decision
A formative check can be brief: a student holds up a response card, writes one sentence, sorts examples, explains a solution to a partner or completes one exit question. The method should match the objective and allow the teacher to see patterns quickly enough to act. A single student answer may be informative but should not be treated as a stable diagnosis without considering context, language demands and other evidence.
Suppose a teacher is introducing equivalent fractions with paper strips. Before moving to comparison, students answer: “Are three-fourths and six-eighths equal? Show how you know.” If most students scale numerator and denominator by the same factor or align equal-sized strips, the teacher can continue with a more complex comparison. If many add two to the numerator and denominator, the teacher should pause and model why equivalent fractions preserve the same proportion rather than just similar-looking numbers.
The sequence from evidence to action is specific. First, state the objective. Next, collect work that makes the target skill visible. Sort responses by the reasoning they show, not only right or wrong. Then select an instructional move that addresses the pattern: another representation, a worked example, guided practice, a small-group prompt or an extension. Finally, check again with a fresh item to see whether the support helped students transfer the idea.
A check should be low enough in consequence that students can reveal uncertainty and receive useful feedback. If every attempt is treated as a final grade, a student may hide confusion or focus on guessing what the teacher wants. Feedback can describe the work and next step: “You used eighths consistently. Now explain how the number line shows the same point.” This is more actionable than a vague “good job” or a mark that identifies an error without helping the student correct it.
A teacher can use student self-assessment as part of formative evidence. Students may mark which criterion they met, point to a confusing step or compare a draft with a model. Self-assessment is not a substitute for teacher judgment, and young students may need concrete prompts. It can reveal confidence or uncertainty that a product alone does not show. Comparing self-assessment with actual work can guide a supportive conversation.
Recognize misconceptions from the pattern of errors
A wrong answer can arise from several causes: a conceptual misconception, a misread direction, a calculation slip, unfamiliar vocabulary, incomplete background knowledge or distraction. The teacher should avoid labeling a learner from one response. Look for a repeated strategy across different examples, ask the student to explain the reasoning, and choose a follow-up item that distinguishes likely explanations.
For example, if a student says one-fourth is larger than one-third because four is larger than three, the response suggests comparing denominators as whole numbers rather than considering the size of equal wholes divided into parts. A teacher can ask the student to draw one-third and one-fourth of equal-length strips, then compare the part sizes. If instead the student shades one-quarter correctly but labels it three-fourths, the issue may be counting or fraction notation rather than the relative-size misconception.
Distractor patterns in selected-response tasks can provide clues, but they do not fully reveal thinking. Ask the student to explain a choice or show work. A constructed response can make strategy visible, while a brief conference or observation can clarify whether the student understands orally but struggles to record the idea. Use the least burdensome additional evidence that answers the instructional question.
Reteaching should change the route to the idea, not merely repeat the same explanation louder or longer. If students cannot connect a written algorithm to equal groups, return to objects, arrays or drawings. If they can compute but not explain, compare multiple representations and ask what stays invariant. After the new instruction, use a parallel problem with different numbers. Repeating the exact original item may measure memory of the answer rather than new understanding.
Some students will be ready to move ahead while others need support. A flexible group can work on a targeted prompt, but groups should change as evidence changes. Do not permanently label a child as “low” based on one unit test. A student may need language scaffolding, additional practice or a more challenging task for different reasons. Use strengths and progress as part of the interpretation.
Summative assessment reports learning at a defined point
A summative assessment is planned to evaluate learning after a defined instructional period. It may be an end-of-unit test, a completed project, a performance, a writing portfolio scored against criteria or a cumulative exam. The result summarizes evidence for a reporting purpose. It should reflect the objectives taught and the performance expected, and its directions, scoring criteria and access conditions should be clear.
A well-aligned unit assessment samples important outcomes without allowing one narrow skill to stand in for an entire subject. If a social studies unit aims at evaluating sources, writing a claim and using evidence, a recall-only quiz will underrepresent the objective. A rubric can distinguish accuracy of claim, relevance of evidence and explanation. The criteria should be explicit and applied consistently across students.
A summative score is not a complete story of learning. It reflects performance on a particular assessment under particular conditions. A student may know a concept but misinterpret a direction; an assessment may omit an important objective; language or access barriers may interfere with showing knowledge. The teacher should report what the evidence supports and use other information when making broader decisions. Do not infer ability or future potential from one score alone.
Summative assessments can still inform future teaching. After results are reported, a teacher can analyze which objectives were mastered, where errors clustered and whether instruction or task design needs adjustment for the next class. That later use does not automatically make the original assessment formative for the students who already completed it. The same evidence may serve a reporting purpose for one decision and an improvement purpose for later planning.
Choose among observation, traditional and standardized measures
Observation is useful when the objective involves a process, interaction or strategy. A teacher can watch how students discuss a text, carry out a science investigation, use manipulatives or organize materials. A focused checklist or brief anecdotal record is more reliable than trying to remember everything. Specify the behavior to observe and collect evidence across more than one moment if the conclusion matters.
Traditional assessments include selected-response items, short answers, essays, quizzes and tests. They can sample knowledge efficiently and support consistent scoring when aligned to the objective. They may provide limited evidence about oral collaboration, practical technique or a student’s reasoning unless the item asks for explanation. A test format is not inherently formative or summative; its purpose and use determine the role.
Standardized assessments administer common procedures and scoring rules to support comparison across students or groups. They can provide useful information about performance relative to a defined reference, but the score should be interpreted according to the assessment’s purpose and technical documentation. A standardized measure may not diagnose the exact misconception behind an error or cover every objective in a local unit. It complements classroom evidence rather than replacing it.
Select an assessment that matches the decision and stakes. A teacher deciding whether to revisit a lesson may use exit slips or a brief conference. A school reporting end-of-year achievement may use a formal measure required by policy. A teacher documenting a student’s oral presentation might use criteria for clarity, evidence and audience awareness. In each case, consider accessibility, directions, scoring time and whether the information is valid for the question being asked.
Fair assessment does not mean giving every learner an identical path to demonstrate a skill when an accommodation or access support is required. Follow the student’s documented plan and school policy. Separate the target construct from barriers that are irrelevant to it. If the learning objective is mathematical reasoning, a reading obstacle unrelated to the target may distort the evidence. However, do not modify a task in a way that removes the skill the assessment is intended to measure.
Use reliability, validity and fairness as practical checks
Validity concerns whether the interpretation and use of assessment evidence are appropriate for the intended purpose. A vocabulary quiz may provide evidence of word recognition but not necessarily deep comprehension. A single multiple-choice item about teamwork cannot fully establish a student’s collaboration skill. Ask whether the task samples the intended learning and whether the conclusion stays within the evidence.
Reliability is about consistency of measurement. Ambiguous directions, inconsistent scoring or a very small sample can produce unstable results. A rubric with observable criteria and anchor examples can help two teachers score work more consistently. Consistency does not automatically make an assessment valid: a test can repeatedly measure the wrong thing. Both the task and interpretation need scrutiny.
Fairness requires attention to access, opportunity to learn, language demands, representation and scoring practices. Review whether an item includes a cultural reference unrelated to the target, whether print size is usable, or whether a student has the required tools. These checks should be tied to the learning goal and relevant policy, not assumptions about individual students. Provide required accommodations and interpret results within their conditions.
A small class example shows the interaction. The objective is to compare fractions using a number line. A test asks students to select a fraction after reading a long word problem with unfamiliar vocabulary. If several students miss it, the teacher should consider both fraction understanding and reading access. A short parallel item with simpler wording, followed by a student explanation, can help determine whether the original result reflected the intended math skill.
Combine evidence without overclaiming
Different evidence sources can strengthen an interpretation when they address the same objective in complementary ways. A teacher might review a written response, observe a student explaining the method and ask a short follow-up question. Agreement across sources supports a more confident instructional decision. Disagreement is also informative: the student may understand orally but need writing support, or may complete a familiar exercise without transferring the concept to a new context.
Keep records concise and tied to the decision. A useful note might state the objective, date, task, observed strategy and next instructional step. Avoid recording only a label such as “struggling.” Describe evidence: “On three equal-whole comparisons, selected the fraction with the larger denominator and explained that it has more pieces.” That record allows the teacher to choose a representation and later check whether the reasoning changed.
Communicate assessment information in language families and students can understand. Explain what the score describes, what it does not describe, and what next step follows. A number without context can mislead. For a summative report, state the criteria and work samples that support the evaluation. For formative feedback, identify a reachable action the learner can take next.
Original Praxis-style assessment questions
During a fractions lesson, many students add the same number to a numerator and denominator to make an equivalent fraction. Which next step is most appropriate?
- Record the quiz grade and begin decimals
- Model equivalent fractions with same-sized visual wholes, then check with a new example
- Repeat the same quiz until the answers change
- Tell students to memorize the rule without discussing the model
A teacher gives a unit test after instruction, scores it against stated objectives and reports the results. What is the primary purpose of this assessment?
- Formative, because every test can adjust instruction
- Summative, because it evaluates learning at the end of a defined unit
- Diagnostic, because it identifies prior knowledge before teaching
- Informal observation, because the teacher reads the responses
In the first item, the key is to interpret a repeated error and select responsive instruction, not to choose a generic test-taking technique. In the second, the end-of-unit purpose makes the assessment summative. A teacher may later use those results to improve future instruction, but that later decision does not change the function it served for the students who completed it.
Fit assessment knowledge to Praxis 5017
The 5017 Study Companion places assessment within each subject area and also includes general assessment outcomes. It asks beginning teachers to design and use formative assessments to adjust instruction, design and interpret summative assessments, recognize misconceptions and choose appropriate tools such as observations, traditional measures and standardized assessments. Many test scenarios combine assessment with curriculum planning or instructional response, so be prepared to connect the evidence to a teaching move.
The exam has 120 selected-response questions in 130 minutes and five approximate content categories: Reading and Language Arts, Mathematics, Science, Social Studies, and Art, Music, and Physical Education. It is a breadth assessment of content and pedagogy, not a dedicated assessment-certification exam.
The two sample items above are original. They are not copied from the ETS Study Companion and do not predict an exact score or question count. Use the code-specific guide for the official detailed outcomes, and apply the same reasoning to unfamiliar classroom cases: identify the target, interpret the evidence, choose the response and check whether it worked.
Common questions
Can the same quiz be formative or summative?
Yes. Its role depends on whether evidence guides instruction during learning or evaluates an endpoint.
Is a formative check always ungraded?
No. Grading alone does not decide purpose, though low-stakes feedback can help reveal current understanding.
What should a teacher do with a misconception?
Identify the reasoning pattern, choose a targeted instructional response and check transfer with a new example.