Futures Basis: Series 3 Exam
Basis is the relationship between a cash-market price and a related futures price.
- A common convention is cash minus futures, but a question may define another.
- Calculate basis at each date, compare the change and connect it to the cash and futures legs of the hedge.
On this page13 sections
- Define basis before using it
- Calculate a basis change
- How basis affects a short hedge
- How basis affects a long hedge
- Sources of basis movement
- Basis versus spreads and outright movement
- Exam method and limitations
- Use the change equation to check the sign
- A basis can cross zero without changing the method
- Expected basis and realized basis answer different questions
- Recognize a basis quote without losing its unit
- The reference month can change the reported basis
- Build a complete hedge result from the final basis
- Common convention
- Basis = cash price - futures price
- Strengthening
- Basis increases under the stated convention
- Why it matters
- Cash and futures may not move in lockstep
- Hedge residual
- Basis risk remains after offsetting price exposure
Define basis before using it
Basis describes the price difference between a cash commodity and a related futures contract. A common expression is cash price minus futures price. If cash is $52.00 and futures are $53.25, basis is -$1.25 under that convention.
The convention is not universal in every market or question. Some sources may use futures minus cash or define a spread in another order. Before computing, write the formula stated in the problem. Many answer errors are not arithmetic failures; they come from reversing the two prices.
Basis is not the same as an outright cash or futures price. Both prices can rise while basis strengthens, weakens or stays constant. Its direction depends on which market moves more relative to the other.
A futures contract is a standardized instrument, while the cash commodity may vary by location, grade, delivery time or transaction terms. The relationship between the two prices therefore matters to hedgers who do not trade the exact deliverable commodity at the designated point.
Calculate a basis change
Suppose cash is $48.60 and futures are $49.40 at the start. Under cash-minus-futures, basis is 48.60 - 49.40 = -$0.80. Later, cash is $47.20 and futures are $47.75, so basis is 47.20 - 47.75 = -$0.55.
Ending basis is 0.25 greater than beginning basis. It strengthened under this convention because it became less negative. The cash and futures prices both fell, but futures fell more in this example, narrowing the difference.
If a later basis were -$1.10, it would be lower than -$0.80 and would have weakened. A negative basis can strengthen by becoming less negative; do not confuse the sign of the basis with the direction of its change.
On a calculation, show each date's subtraction and then ending minus beginning basis. This two-step method reduces the chance of assigning the wrong direction from visual intuition alone.
How basis affects a short hedge
A producer who expects to sell cash later may short futures. The effective sale proceeds equal cash revenue plus the futures gain or loss, before costs. If cash and futures prices move in parallel, the hedge may be close to the expected price. If basis changes, the outcome differs.
Take a one-unit illustration. A producer shorts futures at $50.00 and later sells the cash commodity at $48.00 while futures settle at $49.00. The futures gain is $1.00 and combined proceeds are $49.00. The final basis is 48 - 49 = -$1.00. The result reflects that final relationship.
If the final cash price is still $48.00 but futures are $48.50, the short futures gain is $1.50 and combined proceeds are $49.50. Under cash-minus-futures, final basis is -$0.50, stronger than -$1.00. In this simplified example, the stronger basis improved the seller's net proceeds.
The examples assume matched quantities and no fees. A producer's actual outcome can also depend on grade, location, timing, contract month, transport and delivery rules. State assumptions rather than claiming basis will behave in a predictable way.
How basis affects a long hedge
A business expecting to buy a commodity may buy futures to offset rising prices. Its effective net purchase cost is cash outlay minus futures gain, or increased by a futures loss. Basis still matters because cash and futures may diverge.
Suppose the buyer pays cash $72.00 and has a $2.00 futures gain. Net cost is $70.00 before fees. If futures entry was $70.50, the futures gain arose from the change to a $72.50 settlement. Under cash-minus-futures, ending basis is -$0.50. The cash purchase and gain combine to the effective cost.
With a different final relationship, the same cash level can pair with a different futures settlement and gain. The buyer's net cost therefore changes. A long hedge can limit exposure to rising prices while leaving uncertainty about the final basis and cash invoice.
When explaining who benefits from strengthening basis, specify the hedge direction and transaction. A basis movement does not have one universal benefit for every hedger. Compute the net cash-plus-futures result rather than relying only on a label.
Sources of basis movement
Location differences can cause a local cash price to diverge from the futures delivery location. A transportation bottleneck or local surplus may widen the difference even if the broader futures market changes little.
Grade or quality differences also matter. A cash commodity that differs from the contract's deliverable grade may trade at a premium or discount. A processor's input specification can create basis exposure even when it uses a related futures contract.
Time and storage affect the relationship. A nearby contract and a later cash sale may not line up perfectly. Seasonal production, inventory levels, financing and storage availability can change the cash-versus-futures relationship.
Cross hedging adds correlation risk. If the cash exposure is hedged with a related but different futures contract, the two prices may not move together consistently. Estimate and monitor that risk; don't claim a perfect offset based only on historical similarity.
Basis versus spreads and outright movement
A calendar spread is the price difference between two futures months; basis is usually cash versus a futures contract. Both are differences, so each requires a stated order. A near-minus-deferred spread can rise while an unrelated cash basis falls.
If July futures are $61.20 and December futures are $62.00, July-minus-December is -$0.80. Later, July is $61.90 and December is $62.40, so the spread is -$0.50 and has strengthened under that convention. This says nothing directly about the local cash price unless the problem links it.
An outright market rally is a change in an individual price. Basis change is relative. A candidate should classify whether the question asks for a cash price, futures price, basis, spread or hedge result before doing arithmetic.
Writing formulas at the top of the page is an effective check: basis = cash - futures; spread = named contract A - named contract B; long P/L = (exit - entry) × contract size × number of contracts. This keeps similar difference calculations from being interchanged.
Exam method and limitations
For a Series 3 problem, identify the stated convention, calculate initial basis, calculate final basis, subtract initial from final and label strengthening or weakening. If a hedge is involved, compute cash and futures results separately before combining them.
Use the contract size and position direction in the prompt. If the position is short, a futures-price decline generally creates a gain; if long, the same decline creates a loss. A basis-only calculation may not require a hedge P/L, so answer only what is asked.
Do not treat an example as a price forecast or trading recommendation. The examples use simple assumed values to teach the arithmetic. Real basis can change unpredictably, and futures carry leverage, liquidity and settlement risks.
The current NFA outline includes hedging and basis concepts. It does not publish a fixed percentage weight for basis questions. Cover it as part of Market Knowledge and practice both the definition and its effect on a hedge.
Use the change equation to check the sign
Let C0 and F0 be beginning cash and futures prices, and C1 and F1 the ending prices. Under cash-minus-futures, the basis change is (C1 - F1) - (C0 - F0). Rearranging gives (C1 - C0) - (F1 - F0): the cash-price change minus the futures-price change. This provides an independent check on the two-date subtraction.
For example, cash rises from $30 to $32 while futures rise from $31 to $34. Beginning basis is -$1 and ending basis is -$2, so basis weakens by $1. The change equation gives a $2 cash increase minus a $3 futures increase, also -$1. A market rally therefore does not establish strengthening basis. The relative movement, rather than either price alone, determines the answer.
A basis can cross zero without changing the method
Suppose beginning cash is $16.20 and futures are $16.50, giving basis -$0.30. Later cash is $17.10 and futures are $17.00, giving +$0.10. Basis strengthened by $0.40. The change is not merely $0.10, because the calculation must include the original negative difference. It is also not a 40% change; these are price units, not a percentage return.
Crossing zero means cash moved from below the selected futures price to above it under this convention. It does not automatically identify why the relationship changed or prove an arbitrage profit. The prices must describe compatible goods, units, times and transaction conditions before a meaningful comparison can be made. A local cash quote and an unrelated futures month do not become economically equivalent just because subtraction is possible.
Expected basis and realized basis answer different questions
A hedger can use expected closing basis for planning, but that estimate is not a confirmed future price. With futures entry at $42 and expected closing basis of -$0.60, a matched hedge suggests an expected effective price of $41.40 before costs. If realized basis is -$0.90, the realized effective price is $41.10. The $0.30 difference comes from the forecast error in basis.
For a seller covering 20,000 matched units, the weaker-than-expected basis reduces proceeds by $6,000 relative to that estimate. For a similarly matched buyer, the same weaker basis reduces procurement cost. State whose outcome is being evaluated and what the comparison benchmark is. A difference from an expected effective price is not necessarily the total futures profit or the business’s overall profit.
Recognize a basis quote without losing its unit
An invented cash quotation might describe a commodity as 15 cents under a specified futures contract. With futures at $4.80 per unit, cash is $4.65 and cash-minus-futures basis is -$0.15 per unit. A quote of 10 cents over instead means cash $4.90 and basis +$0.10. Write the underlying month and unit before interpreting the words under or over.
Do not subtract 15 whole dollars from a price expressed in dollars when the differential is 15 cents. If the question then asks for an amount on 5,000 units, a $0.15 per-unit differential represents $750. That total is a price differential across the stated quantity, not necessarily profit on a tradable position. Quotes using other conventions must be converted according to the information in the problem.
The reference month can change the reported basis
At the same instant, assume local cash is $20, nearby futures are $20.50 and deferred futures are $21.20. Basis against nearby is -$0.50, while basis against deferred is -$1.20. The cash commodity has not acquired two different spot prices. The reference futures contract changed. Reporting basis without identifying the relevant contract month leaves an important part of the comparison unstated.
A hedge rolled to a later month therefore needs care when comparing basis records across dates. A changed reference can affect the displayed difference alongside genuine movement in local conditions. Keep the closing result on the old futures position, the opening price of the new one and the associated costs separate. A simple initial-futures-plus-final-basis formula for one unchanged matched contract should not silently omit the effects of a roll.
Build a complete hedge result from the final basis
For a matched short hedge, effective sale proceeds per unit equal final cash price plus the futures gain: C1 + F0 - F1. Under the stated convention, this is F0 + final basis. For a matched long hedge, effective purchase cost is C1 minus the futures gain F1 - F0, giving the same expression. Identical algebra does not mean the buyer and seller prefer the same movement.
A fictional seller shorts at $60 and finishes with cash $57.80 and futures $58.40. The futures gain is $1.60 and proceeds per unit are $59.40. Final basis is -$0.60, independently giving $60 - $0.60 = $59.40. For a buyer who entered long at $60 under those same ending prices, the futures loss is $1.60 and effective purchase cost is also $59.40. Both calculations are before fees and assume matching units.
These identities are useful checking tools. If the cash-plus-futures calculation and the basis expression disagree, inspect the long or short sign, the reference month, contract quantity and quotation units. If exposure is only partially hedged or a different underlying is used, document that departure rather than forcing the one-unit matched formula onto the entire transaction.
Common questions
What is the usual futures basis formula?
A common convention is cash price minus futures price, but follow the convention stated in the question.
What does strengthening basis mean?
Under cash-minus-futures, basis has increased; calculate the beginning and ending values to confirm.
Does a hedge eliminate basis risk?
No. Cash and futures prices may not move by the same amount.