Option Payoffs: FRM Part I
An option’s terminal payoff depends on the underlying price relative to its strike.
- Net profit also includes the premium and any contract multiplier or costs.
- Calculate payoff first, then subtract the premium for a long position.
- Separate terminal payoff from premium-adjusted profit and account for position direction.
On this page9 sections
- Payoff versus profit
- Long call and long put examples
- Short options and risk
- Build the expiration payoff before adding the premium
- Payoff diagrams and piecewise functions
- Combine options by adding their position payoffs
- Do not confuse expiration payoff with an option's current price
- A quick option calculation checklist
- Check breakeven and maximum loss separately
Payoff versus profit
A call gives its holder the right, not the obligation, to buy the underlying at strike K. At expiration, the long-call payoff per unit is max(ST - K, 0), where ST is the terminal underlying price.
A put gives its holder the right to sell at K. Its terminal payoff per unit is max(K - ST, 0). The holder may let an out-of-the-money option expire without exercising.
Profit differs from payoff because the option was purchased or sold for a premium. For a long option, subtract the premium from terminal payoff. For a short option, reverse the payoff and add the premium, before fees, financing, or contract multipliers.
An option can finish in the money and still create a net loss. A call with strike 60 and premium 12, when the underlying ends at 70, pays 10 but has net profit -2 per unit.
Long call and long put examples
For a long call with strike 60 and premium 4, terminal prices 55, 62, and 70 yield payoffs 0, 2, and 10. Net profits are -4, -2, and +6 per unit, ignoring costs and multipliers.
The long-call breakeven at expiration is K + premium, or 64 in this example. Above 64, net profit is positive; below 64, the maximum loss is the premium paid, assuming the position is held to expiration and costs are ignored.
For a long put with strike 60 and premium 3, at terminal prices 70, 58, and 50, payoffs are 0, 2, and 10. Net profits are -3, -1, and +7. Breakeven is K - premium = 57.
A payoff graph has a flat region where the option expires out of the money and a sloped region after the strike. Profit shifts the payoff graph down for a long position by the premium.
Short options and risk
A short call’s terminal profit per unit is premium - max(ST - K, 0). If the underlying rises substantially, the loss can grow without a fixed cap in the basic model. The premium is the maximum gain before costs.
A short put’s terminal profit is premium - max(K - ST, 0). The loss is limited by the underlying falling toward zero but can still be substantial relative to the premium received.
For a short call with strike 60 and premium 4, terminal prices 55, 62, and 70 produce profits +4, +2, and -6. These reverse the long call’s payoff effect, but the short writer’s risk profile is not simply “collect income.”
Actual option positions can involve American exercise, early assignment, dividends, volatility changes, and margin. A terminal payoff chart omits those path-dependent and market-pricing considerations.
Build the expiration payoff before adding the premium
A reliable method is to evaluate the exercise rule first. For a call, compare the underlying price with the strike. If it is below the strike, payoff is zero; if above, subtract the strike. For a put, compare the strike with the underlying. If the underlying exceeds the strike, payoff is zero; if below, subtract the underlying from the strike. Only after that step do you account for the premium and position direction.
Use a small table of terminal prices rather than jumping to a remembered diagram. For a long put with strike 50 and premium 3, terminal prices 42, 50, and 57 produce payoffs 8, 0, and 0, and profits 5, -3, and -3. The flat region above the strike reflects the right not to exercise; the loss is capped at the premium for a buyer who holds the option to expiration.
A short option reverses the buyer's payoff exposure but not necessarily its real-world risk constraints. A short call receives the premium, then owes the call payoff at expiration. If the underlying price rises far above the strike, the loss can grow substantially. A short put's loss is limited by the underlying falling toward zero under the simple equity example, but can still be much larger than the premium received.
Payoff diagrams and piecewise functions
For a long call, the payoff is zero to the left of the strike and rises with slope one to the right. Its profit line sits below the payoff by the amount of the premium paid. A long put's payoff slopes downward as the underlying rises below the strike, then becomes zero above it; its profit is lower by the premium. Labeling the axes and marking the strike and breakeven makes the diagram easier to interpret.
For a short call, the expiration profit starts at the premium received and then declines as the underlying rises above the strike. For a short put, the premium cushions losses only until the underlying falls far enough below the strike. When plotting, distinguish the payoff to the option holder from the profit of the option writer. Reusing the buyer's line and merely changing the label is a common sign error.
At-the-money, in-the-money, and out-of-the-money describe the relation between spot and strike, not whether the buyer is profitable after premium. For a call, spot above strike is in the money; for a put, spot below strike is in the money. A premium includes time value as well as intrinsic value before expiry, so current option value is not always equal to the terminal payoff formula.
Combine options by adding their position payoffs
A spread combines two or more option positions. To find its expiration result, calculate each leg separately at the same terminal price, multiply by the position quantity and contract multiplier if given, then add the results. Track premium cash flows separately. This avoids trying to memorize the entire strategy shape before understanding each leg.
Suppose a trader buys a call at strike 50 for a premium of 5 and sells a call at strike 60 for a premium of 2, with equal contract units. The initial net premium is 3 paid. At expiry of 55, the lower-strike call pays 5 and the higher-strike call pays zero, so profit is 2. At 65, payoffs are 15 and -5, so the net payoff is 10 and profit is 7. Above the higher strike, the short call offsets further gains from the long call, limiting the spread's upside.
A protective put combines a long underlying position with a long put. The put creates a floor below the strike at expiry, after accounting for its premium, while the underlying retains upside. A covered call combines a long underlying with a short call: premium income offsets part of a decline, but gains above the strike are surrendered. These payoff shapes are useful for understanding exposure; they do not establish that a strategy is suitable or profitable.
Do not confuse expiration payoff with an option's current price
Before expiration, an option's market price can exceed intrinsic value because time remains for the underlying to move. The simple max expressions apply to payoff at expiry, not to the option premium today. Current value depends on time, volatility, interest rates, expected distributions, and contract terms. A question asking for current option value may require a pricing model rather than a payoff calculation.
Early exercise rights also depend on option style and contract rules. An American option can be exercised before expiration, while a European option is exercisable only at expiry. Even when early exercise is permitted, whether it is economically sensible depends on dividends, financing, and remaining time value. Read the question's exercise assumptions instead of applying an expiration-only result to an earlier date.
Contract multipliers turn per-unit values into contract values. If an option covers 100 units, a $6 profit per unit corresponds to $600 before costs, assuming the stated multiplier and one contract. Never add a per-share premium to a total contract payoff without matching the units. Some derivatives use different multipliers or settlement conventions, so use what the problem supplies.
A quick option calculation checklist
Identify whether the position is long or short, call or put, and whether the question asks for payoff, profit, or current value. Write the expiration formula, substitute the terminal price, and compare the result with the premium. Apply quantity and multiplier last. Then check limiting behavior: a long call payoff cannot be negative, a long put payoff cannot be negative, and a buyer's expiration loss is bounded by premium under the basic payoff setup.
If an answer choice equals intrinsic value but the question asks for profit, inspect whether the premium was omitted. If the result has the wrong sign, check whether the writer's obligation was included. If the amount is too large, check the multiplier. These simple checks are especially useful in timed questions because option notation can make a short calculation look more complicated than it is.
Check breakeven and maximum loss separately
For the long call with strike 60 and premium 4, breakeven at expiry is 64. The maximum loss is the premium, 4 per unit, because the option can expire worthless. The upside is unbounded in the simple underlying model because the call payoff grows as the underlying price rises. Those are different properties and should be stated separately.
| Position | Expiry payoff | Buyer or writer profit treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Long call | Max(S-K,0) | Subtract premium paid |
| Long put | Max(K-S,0) | Subtract premium paid |
| Short call | -max(S-K,0) | Add premium received |
| Short put | -max(K-S,0) | Add premium received |
For a long put with strike 50 and premium 3, breakeven is 47. The maximum loss is the premium, while the maximum gross payoff occurs if the underlying falls to zero and is 50 per unit in a nonnegative-price model. Net profit at zero would be 47 per unit before costs. The model assumptions matter if the underlying can take negative values or uses a different settlement convention.
Common questions
What is the difference between payoff and profit?
Payoff is the exercise value at expiry. Profit also includes the premium paid or received and, depending on the problem, costs and financing.
When does a long call break even?
At expiration, the basic long-call breakeven is strike plus premium, before transaction costs and financing.
Can an in-the-money option lose money?
Yes. If its intrinsic value is less than the premium paid, the buyer’s net profit is negative even when the option is in the money.
Is current option price equal to expiration payoff?
No. Before expiry, time value and other pricing inputs affect the option’s market value. The max payoff formulas apply at expiration.