Sitonce
Country: US
Show exams for United States Hong Kong
Sign in

Forward and Futures Prices: FRM Part I

Updated 8 min read
Key takeaway

Forward and futures prices reflect the underlying spot price adjusted for financing, income, storage and other carry effects.

  • Futures are standardized and marked to market daily; theoretical price equality with forwards depends on assumptions.
  • Match carry inputs and quotation units to the underlying and contract assumptions.
On this page9 sections
  1. Arbitrage intuition
  2. Worked example with known income
  3. Start with the carry relationship
  4. Match the underlying to its carry costs and benefits
  5. Calculate a currency forward with explicit units
  6. What distinguishes a forward from a futures contract
  7. Read basis and convergence carefully
  8. Common calculation checks
  9. Distinguish a new forward price from contract value later

Arbitrage intuition

If a theoretical forward price is too high relative to spot and carry, an arbitrageur may buy the underlying, finance the purchase, and sell the forward, subject to market access and costs. If the forward is too low, a reverse cash-and-carry trade may be considered.

These trades rely on executable prices, financing, storage, borrow availability, settlement terms, and ability to transact in both markets. The textbook relation is a no-arbitrage benchmark, not a guarantee that a practical trade is risk free.

Worked example with known income

Suppose a hypothetical share trades at $100 and the present value of a known pre-maturity dividend is $2. With a continuously compounded financing rate of 5%, the simple known-income model gives F = (100 - 2)e^0.05, or about $103.02.

If the dividend were instead represented by a continuous yield of 2%, the approximate relation F = 100e^((0.05 - 0.02)×1) gives about $103.05. The small difference reflects different dividend assumptions, not arithmetic inconsistency.

For either model, identify when the income is paid and whether the amount is known. A discrete dividend and a continuous yield are not interchangeable without an approximation.

Futures prices may diverge from these forward prices when daily settlement and interest-rate variation matter. If a problem assumes deterministic interest rates, the distinction may disappear in the theoretical calculation.

Start with the carry relationship

A forward price links today's spot price to the cost of holding the underlying until delivery. For a non-income asset with continuous financing rate r and time T, the idealized relationship is F = S₀e^(rT). If the spot price is 100, the financing rate is 4 percent per year, and delivery is in half a year, the model gives 100e^(0.04×0.5), or about 102.02. This assumes frictionless financing, no storage cost or income, and feasible borrowing and short selling.

The carry model has a practical interpretation: the long forward agrees to pay at delivery instead of buying the asset now and financing it. The forward price therefore reflects the spot value carried forward. It is not simply a forecast of the future spot price. Expectations may influence trading, but the no-arbitrage price is derived from the replicating cash-and-carry strategy under the model assumptions.

For a known cash income paid before delivery, the present value of that income reduces the cost of carrying the asset. In a simple discrete-cash-flow setup, the forward price is the financed value of spot less the financed value of interim benefits, using compatible discounting. For a continuously compounded dividend yield q, a common equity-index relation is F = S₀e^((r-q)T). State which convention the problem gives before choosing the formula.

Match the underlying to its carry costs and benefits

Physical commodities can incur storage and insurance costs. A simplified continuous-cost model may add a storage rate u to financing, while convenience yield y represents the noncash benefit of having the physical commodity available. One common relationship is F = S₀e^((r+u-y)T). These terms have economic meaning: storage raises the cost of carry, while a convenience benefit lowers the futures price relative to a model with no such benefit.

Do not insert dividend yield into a commodity formula or convenience yield into an equity-index question unless the problem defines those terms. A commodity's seasonal availability, storage capacity, and inventory conditions can affect the benefit of physical ownership. A stock index has cash dividends; a currency pair has two interest rates. The underlying determines which carry components belong in the model.

For foreign exchange, identify the quotation convention first. If the quote is domestic currency per unit of foreign currency, the relative interest rates enter with a direction determined by that quote. Reversing the quote reverses the rate relationship. A safe method is to write the currencies and the investment strategy in words, then check that the forward quote has the same units as spot.

Calculate a currency forward with explicit units

Suppose spot is 1.10 domestic currency units per foreign currency unit, the domestic continuously compounded rate is 5 percent, the foreign rate is 2 percent, and maturity is one year. Under the stated quote convention and idealized no-arbitrage assumptions, the forward is 1.10e^((0.05-0.02)×1), approximately 1.1335 domestic units per foreign unit. The result is higher than spot because the domestic rate exceeds the foreign rate in this quote convention.

If the quote were foreign currency per domestic unit, one could invert the spot quote and exchange the rate roles. Do not keep the original numerator and denominator while swapping only a rate sign. Units make the relationship auditable: the quoted forward must still mean the specified number of domestic units for one foreign unit.

For simple interest rather than continuous compounding, the problem may use a ratio such as S₀(1+r_dT)/(1+r_fT). Do not mix that expression with continuously compounded rates. A small numerical difference can reveal a compounding mismatch even when the broad direction is correct.

What distinguishes a forward from a futures contract

A forward is generally a customized agreement between counterparties, with terms such as amount and delivery date set for the contract. A futures contract is standardized and traded through an exchange clearing structure. Standardization supports secondary trading, while bilateral customization can better match a user's exposure. The actual legal, collateral, and settlement terms depend on the contract and market.

Futures gains and losses are settled through daily marking to market, with margin arrangements and clearinghouse procedures. A forward commonly settles at maturity, although collateral or interim payment arrangements may apply under its documentation. This difference changes the timing of cash flows and creates liquidity needs even when terminal economics appear similar.

Because futures cash flows occur earlier, the futures price can differ from the forward price when interest rates are stochastic and correlated with the underlying price changes. Under simplifying conditions, including deterministic rates, the two theoretical prices may be equal. Do not claim universal equality. A strong answer identifies the settlement timing and the assumptions required for price equivalence.

Read basis and convergence carefully

Basis is often defined as spot minus futures price, although the convention can vary by market. State the convention before interpreting a sign. As a futures contract approaches delivery, its price typically converges toward the relevant spot price for a deliverable contract, subject to quality, location, timing, and settlement details. A hedge can still face basis risk if the exposure and contract do not match.

A farmer hedging a local crop price with a standardized futures contract may reduce broad commodity-price risk but remain exposed to local transportation, grade, and timing differences. If local cash prices weaken relative to the futures contract, the hedge may not offset the full revenue change. This is not necessarily a failure of the futures formula; it is a mismatch between the hedged exposure and the contract's reference.

For a hedger, distinguish spot exposure from futures position. A producer expecting to sell an asset may sell futures to offset a price decline, while a buyer needing the asset later may buy futures against a price rise. The hedge direction follows the underlying business risk. A correct futures price calculation does not by itself determine whether the position is a hedge or a speculation.

Common calculation checks

Check maturity in years if the rate is annual, and convert quoted percentages to decimals before exponentiation. Confirm whether the rate is simple, periodically compounded, or continuous. Include the correct income, storage, or foreign-rate terms. Then compare the result with spot: financing alone usually puts a non-income asset's forward above spot when rates are positive, while an income yield can reduce that premium.

If a result looks backward, do not force it to match a memorized rule. Recheck the FX quotation direction, the sign of the dividend or foreign rate, and whether the problem asks for a forward price or a contract value after inception. Price and value are different: the delivery price is set at the start, while the contract's current value can become positive or negative as market inputs change.

Distinguish a new forward price from contract value later

At inception, the delivery price is typically set so the idealized forward contract has zero value, ignoring credit, collateral, and transaction costs. Later, the market forward price for the remaining term can differ from the contracted delivery price. The contract then has value to one side and an equal opposite value to the other under the simplified model.

Underlying featureCarry effect in simplified modelCheck
FinancingRaises forward priceRate and maturity units
Cash income or dividend yieldLowers carry pricePayment or yield convention
Commodity storageRaises carry costPhysical contract terms
Convenience yieldLowers modeled priceUnderlying-specific benefit

For an asset with no income, if spot rises above the present value implied by the original delivery price and remaining carry, the long forward may have positive value. This is not the same calculation as setting a new fair forward price from today’s spot. Read whether the question asks for quoted delivery price, current contract value, or terminal payoff.

Credit exposure and collateral can alter the practical value of a bilateral forward. A counterparty may fail to perform when the contract is valuable to you. Futures clearing and margin reduce some bilateral exposures but create liquidity demands. The textbook carry equation isolates price relationships and should not be mistaken for a full counterparty-risk analysis.

Common questions

Are forward and futures prices always equal?

No. They can be equal under simplifying assumptions such as deterministic interest rates. Daily futures settlement can make their prices differ when rates and underlying changes are correlated.

Does a forward price predict future spot?

Not necessarily. The no-arbitrage forward price reflects spot and carry assumptions; it is not simply a forecast of future spot.

What changes a commodity futures price?

Financing, storage costs, and convenience yield can affect carry. Use the factors and conventions supplied for the underlying.

Why does an FX quote convention matter?

The relative interest-rate relationship depends on which currency is quoted per unit of the other. Keep the forward’s units consistent with spot.