Fund Management Conflicts of Interest: HKSI Paper 6
Fund managers should identify and manage actual and potential conflicts so clients are treated fairly and their interests are protected.
- Controls can include segregation, independent review, fair allocation, arm's-length terms, monitoring and disclosure where required.
- Disclosure alone does not make an unmanaged conflict acceptable.
On this page10 sections
- What counts as a conflict
- Common conflict patterns
- Disclosure is only one part of the response
- Fair allocation of investment opportunities
- Related-party transactions and cross trades
- Controls should match the risk
- Practice a structured analysis
- Personal dealing and information barriers
- Test whether a control is effective
- A final point for Paper 6 candidates
- Primary source
- SFC Fund Manager Code of Conduct, fifth edition, October 2024
- Paper 6 area
- Asset management regulations
- Common conflicts
- Personal dealing, related parties, allocation, cross trades and incentives
- Core test
- Identify the interest, affected client and effective control
What counts as a conflict
A conflict arises when a manager's interests, an associated person's interests or the interests of one client may diverge from those of another client. It can be actual or potential. A manager may have an incentive to allocate a trade to one fund, direct business to an affiliate, value an asset optimistically or let an employee trade ahead of clients. The conflict may be manageable, but the firm needs arrangements to identify it and protect clients from unfair treatment.
Paper 6 places conflicts within the Fund Manager Code of Conduct and broader SFC conduct framework. SFC's code page identifies the fifth edition dated October 2024. For each scenario, ask whose interests are in tension, who makes the decision, which clients are affected and what arrangements operate before, during and after the decision. A label such as 'conflict' is only the beginning of the analysis.
Common conflict patterns
| Conflict pattern | Why it matters | Control questions |
|---|---|---|
| Personal dealing | Employee may benefit from information or access connected to client activity | Are interests declared, restricted, monitored and independently reviewed? |
| Scarce allocation | Several clients want the same investment | Is there a fair policy applied consistently and documented? |
| Related-party trade | Manager or affiliate may benefit from a transaction | Are terms arm's length, independently assessed and approved? |
| Cross trade | One client may receive a different price or timing than another | Is the transaction permitted, fairly priced and subject to review? |
| Compensation incentive | Fees or performance pay may influence product or account decisions | Do controls protect client outcomes and identify biased decisions? |
Disclosure is only one part of the response
Disclosure may be required when a conflict is material, but disclosure alone does not show that the manager has managed it. The firm still needs effective arrangements that identify and prevent unfair treatment, avoid the conflict where appropriate, or control it through a suitable process. A disclosure document cannot turn a self-serving transaction into a fair one. The manager should assess whether its systems, people and incentives can manage the conflict in the client's interests.
For an exam item, distinguish transparency from control. Telling investors that an affiliate may benefit is different from checking whether the transaction is on arm's-length terms, obtaining independent approval and monitoring the decision. Likewise, an employee's declaration of a personal interest does not automatically permit the employee to participate. Restriction, recusal, information barriers or independent review may be needed, depending on the facts and policy.
Fair allocation of investment opportunities
Allocation becomes a conflict when more than one fund or account is eligible for a limited investment. A manager should not favour the account that generates the largest fee, belongs to a preferred investor or benefits the employee. An allocation policy should define how orders are grouped, divided and adjusted, while allowing for mandate restrictions and available cash. The firm should retain records sufficient to explain how a particular allocation was made and monitor outcomes for patterns of unfairness.
Suppose two funds submit eligible orders for an oversubscribed new issue, but only half the requested amount is available. A documented pro-rata method could be one fair approach, but the proper method depends on mandate fit, order size and the policy. The manager should not improvise after learning the final allocation in order to reward one client. If circumstances require an exception, it should be justified, reviewed and recorded. The policy's purpose is fair treatment, not merely completing an allocation spreadsheet.
Related-party transactions and cross trades
A related-party transaction can benefit the manager, an affiliate or a connected person. The firm should identify the relationship, assess whether the transaction is permitted and determine how fair terms will be established. Independent pricing or review may be important, particularly if the asset is illiquid or the affiliate controls the available information. The transaction should be consistent with the fund's interests and governing documents. If the conflict cannot be managed effectively, the firm should not proceed simply because a disclosure exists.
A cross trade between client accounts also requires care because one account buys while another sells. The manager must consider whether the transaction is allowed, whether pricing and timing are fair to both clients, and whether any approvals or disclosures apply. A trade that is convenient for the manager can still disadvantage one client. Avoid assuming that matching two client orders automatically makes the transaction fair or permitted.
Controls should match the risk
Common controls include a conflict register, pre-approval, restricted lists, personal-dealing rules, segregation of duties, independent valuation, fair allocation procedures, surveillance, committee review and client disclosure. A control must be used, monitored and supported by records. A policy that exists on paper but is not enforced provides little protection. Senior management should receive information about significant conflicts and recurring exceptions so that it can assess whether the arrangements work.
Controls can also create new conflicts. For example, a committee may be nominally independent while its members report to the executive whose transaction they review. Examine the substance of independence, access to information and authority to challenge. In a multiple-choice question, prefer a response that addresses the source of the conflict and adds independent oversight over one that merely restates a general duty.
Practice a structured analysis
Use this sequence on a scenario: identify the competing interests; identify the client or clients exposed; check whether the activity is permitted; choose a control that prevents or manages the unfair outcome; consider independent review and disclosure; and preserve evidence. Do not jump to a sanction or legal conclusion before you know the rule and facts. The SFC may take enforcement action for misconduct, but the precise result depends on the conduct, evidence and circumstances.
For study, make one example for personal dealing, one for allocation, one for related-party transactions and one for incentives. State the conflict in a single sentence and name the control that operates before any client harm occurs. Then add what monitoring would detect a failure. This technique connects the Fund Manager Code to internal controls and helps you handle Paper 6 scenarios that combine several syllabus topics.
The Paper 6 syllabus identifies the Fund Manager Code as a core subject. Use the current guide for exam scope and the current SFC code for authoritative detail. HKSI lists guide version 2.7 as published in November 2025; its public syllabus PDF is effective 12 January 2026. Check HKSI's update page near your sitting for a later edition.
Personal dealing and information barriers
Personal dealing can conflict with client interests when staff trade using information or access related to firm activity. Controls can include declarations, pre-clearance, restricted lists, trading windows, surveillance and escalation. The right mix depends on risk and the firm's business. A declaration filed after an employee trades does not prevent misuse or unfair timing. Ask whether the control operated before the trade and whether the firm could detect a breach.
Information barriers can limit sensitive information flow between teams, but a barrier is useful only when access, communication and exceptions are monitored. If staff can bypass it, stronger restrictions or independent review may be needed. Match the control to the conflict: allocation needs fairness, personal dealing needs employee controls, and a related-party transaction needs arm's-length assessment and oversight.
Conflicts recur, so management should review patterns rather than treat every event as isolated. Repeated exceptions may signal an incentive problem or poorly designed control. Management information can show who benefited, which clients were affected and whether overrides cluster around one desk. Documented review lets the firm change controls before further harm. Conflict principles connect to governance, records and client-interest duties elsewhere in Paper 6.
Test whether a control is effective
Ask what the control prevents, who owns it, how exceptions are approved and what evidence shows it worked. A conflict register can identify a relationship but cannot by itself ensure fair treatment. A wall-crossing process needs access monitoring. A pre-clearance process needs timely review. A valuation committee needs independence and reliable information. These implementation details help distinguish meaningful arrangements from a policy that exists only in a manual.
A final point for Paper 6 candidates
A conflict can exist even when no client has yet suffered a loss. The risk may arise from incentives or access before a transaction is completed. Preventive controls therefore matter: identify interests early, restrict participation where needed and review proposed decisions independently. If the firm waits until after a loss to consider fairness, it has missed the opportunity to manage the conflict at the point when it could affect a client's outcome.