HKSI Paper 3 Sample Questions and Answers
These original Paper 3 practice questions test futures margin, client money, reportable positions and OTC derivatives reporting.
- Each scenario is newly written for study and is not an HKSI examination item.
- Work through the facts, identify the responsible actor and rule, then check detailed requirements against current primary sources.
On this page11 sections
- How to use these questions
- Question 1: Margin shortfall
- Question 2: Client money for a futures margin obligation
- Question 3: Reportable futures position
- Question 4: OTC derivatives reporting and clearing
- Turn explanations into revision
- How Question 1 transfers to a new case
- How Question 2 tests timing
- How Question 3 tests aggregation
- How Question 4 tests effective dates
- A short self-marking rubric
How to use these questions
These four questions are original study examples for HKSI Paper 3, Regulation of Derivatives. They are not HKSI examination items and do not reproduce the eStudy Guide. They cover different syllabus areas to practise identifying the actor, trigger, rule and next step. The public outline gives no topic weighting, so this small set is not a representative blueprint or prediction of what will appear.
Try each question before opening its explanation. State why the selected answer fits the facts and why the nearest distractor does not. When a rule depends on a current schedule or technical threshold, use the primary source named below. These examples teach reasoning sequences, not all details of the applicable law.
- Question 1
- Futures client margin shortfall
- Question 2
- Client-money settlement exception
- Question 3
- Reportable futures position
- Question 4
- OTC reporting and clearing scope
Question 1: Margin shortfall
A futures broker determines that a client has a margin shortfall after an adverse market move. The client asks to open another position that would increase the shortfall and says a transfer will arrive tomorrow. What is the strongest response under prudent futures risk controls?
- A. Accept because the client has promised to pay.
- B. Lend the client money for margin and permit the trade.
- C. Prevent a position that increases the shortfall, issue and monitor a margin call, and follow the documented close-out process if the deadline is missed.
- D. Ignore the shortfall if the exchange itself has not liquidated the position.
Best answer: C. The SFC Risk Management Guidelines for Licensed Persons Dealing in Futures Contracts call for prudent thresholds for margin calls, stopping risk-increasing positions when there is a shortfall, prompt collection and a documented response if the client does not meet the call. A promise is not collateral. The broker should manage the exposure before the clearing chain becomes impaired.
A is wrong because the client’s expected transfer does not remove current shortfall risk. B conflicts with the general guideline against lending to enable a client to meet margin, subject to a defined concessionary arrangement. D confuses client-level broker controls with a clearing house action. The broker’s duty can arise before the exchange liquidates anything. In a live case, the agreement, current guideline and the firm’s approved procedures govern the next step.
Question 2: Client money for a futures margin obligation
A licensed corporation receives a client payment that is matched to a futures contract. The amount is required for settlement or margin for the relevant dealing within the next two business days. Which analysis is strongest?
- A. Every receipt in a futures account is excluded from the Client Money Rules.
- B. Apply the specific statutory settlement or margin treatment only after confirming the receipt, purpose and timing satisfy the rule; document the subsequent movement.
- C. Treat any expected margin call as sufficient to exclude the receipt, even when no dealing is identified.
- D. Transfer the funds to any group company without checking authority.
Best answer: B. The Client Money Rules provide a specific exclusion for money required for settlement or margin obligations on securities or futures contracts dealt within the next two business days after receipt. The condition turns on purpose and timing. A turns a narrow exception into a blanket treatment. C lacks a matched dealing and confirmed requirement. D ignores the required basis and authority for transfers.
The firm should keep evidence linking the customer, trade, amount, time and margin or settlement obligation. If the exception does not apply, the client money segregation rule and its relevant time requirements must be considered. A receipt that cannot be identified should be investigated and reconciled, not allocated by guess. Check the current statutory text and policy because an FAQ explanation is not the full rule.
Question 3: Reportable futures position
A manager has discretion over a fund’s futures positions at two brokers. The accounts are individually below the contract’s current reporting level, but the aggregated position reaches that level. What should happen?
- A. No notice is due because neither broker’s account independently reaches the threshold.
- B. The person holding or controlling the aggregate position should ensure the required notice is filed, directly or through an agreed agent, and continue monitoring the position.
- C. Wait until the prescribed maximum is reached before reporting.
- D. Ask the clearing house to file because the client used a clearing participant.
Best answer: B. The position-limit analysis concerns holdings or control and can require aggregation. A reportable level triggers notification; it is separate from the prescribed maximum. Under the SFC’s July 2025 guidance, a notice is generally due within one business day following the first day and each succeeding day the person continues to hold or control the reportable position, with specific treatment for holiday contracts.
A is wrong because an account-by-account view can conceal an aggregated position. C confuses a reporting trigger with a limit. D assumes the clearing house has the reporting responsibility. An Exchange Participant or agent can file where agreed, but the person with the position remains responsible for ensuring compliance. Exact thresholds and netting rules depend on the current contract schedule, so do not use a historical example as a universal number.
Question 4: OTC derivatives reporting and clearing
A Hong Kong licensed corporation enters an OTC interest rate swap. Operations assumes that if the trade must be reported, it must also be centrally cleared. Which response is best?
- A. Treat all reportable swaps as automatically subject to mandatory clearing.
- B. Test reporting and clearing separately against their current transaction, entity and counterparty scope conditions.
- C. Skip reporting if the transaction is not mandatorily clearable.
- D. Use a 2022 reporting data template without checking later amendments.
Best answer: B. Hong Kong has separate reporting and clearing rules. Reporting applies to specified products and entities, while mandatory clearing covers a narrower scope subject to product and counterparty conditions. A trade can be reportable without being mandatorily clearable. Conversely, a clearing analysis does not answer the reporting question. Current law, notices and technical instructions determine scope and data.
The SFC says enhanced reporting data requirements took effect on 29 September 2025, including UTI, UPI and critical data elements, with ISO 20022 XML adopted. D risks applying obsolete technical instructions. C also wrongly treats separate regimes as substitutes. A correct operational process identifies the reporting entity, validates the message, checks repository acknowledgments and retains evidence, then performs the independent clearing and recordkeeping analysis.
Turn explanations into revision
The answer letter is the least valuable part of a review. For each question, note the controlling fact, the source, the responsible actor and the reason the closest wrong answer fails. Then change one fact and answer again. If the client paid before a shortfall rather than after it, if the manager lacked discretion, or if the OTC counterparty changed category, would the outcome change? Explaining that boundary is how you check whether the principle transfers.
The syllabus version and source date matter. The public Paper 3 outline provides outcomes rather than complete operational instructions. For exact current requirements, consult the SFC risk guidance, client-money FAQ and legislation, the current position-limits rules and guidance, or the SFC OTC regime page and technical documentation. Keep these original exercises separate from official HKSI practice material.
How Question 1 transfers to a new case
Change the facts so the margin shortfall is cured before the customer places the additional order. The analysis may then turn on whether the firm has confirmed the funds, recalculated net equity and restored compliance with its limit. A promise to pay remains different from cleared funds. If the customer is eligible for concessionary margining, check that the exchange or clearing-house conditions and firm controls are met. Do not generalize one answer without retesting the material facts.
How Question 2 tests timing
Suppose the receipt is not linked to a specific futures transaction, or the expected margin obligation falls outside the stated two-business-day period. The exemption may not apply on those facts. The firm must classify the funds under the current Client Money Rules and apply the ordinary requirements where relevant. The point of the question is not to memorize “futures cash is exempt”; it is to verify a qualifying purpose and timing before relying on the exception.
How Question 3 tests aggregation
Try the same position facts with an investment manager that cannot make trading decisions. Control may be different, and the aggregation analysis must follow the SFC guidance and legal facts. Then change the account periods or product. Netting and futures-equivalent calculations are schedule-specific. A correct solution names the person, contract period and current reporting threshold rather than citing a remembered number from another contract.
How Question 4 tests effective dates
Change the transaction event to an amendment after the reporting enhancement date. Ask whether the event must be reported, what lifecycle data is required, and which identifier or message standard applies under current instructions. A trade repository receipt should be reconciled and retained. If the question instead asks whether a transaction must be cleared, perform that scope analysis independently; reporting and clearing remain different obligations.
A short self-marking rubric
Give yourself one point for identifying the governing regime, one for the correct actor, one for the fact that triggers the duty and one for the next action or deadline. The rubric is a study aid, not an HKSI marking scheme. If you choose the correct letter but cannot explain the source or rejected alternatives, mark the concept for review. This is especially useful when a question contains two simultaneous obligations.
Common questions
Are these official HKSI Paper 3 questions?
No. They are original study scenarios created for this article and are not official HKSI examination items.
Do these four examples reflect the actual exam topic distribution?
No. The public syllabus does not publish topic weights, and four sample questions cannot predict the composition of a sitting.
Which source should I use for detailed rule thresholds?
Use the current relevant legislation, SFC guidance and HKEX rules or procedures. Thresholds and technical details can depend on the instrument and current version.