Acting in Concert: HKSI Paper 17
“Acting in concert” describes cooperation between persons to obtain or consolidate control of a company.
- For Paper 17, identify the relationship, apply any Code presumption and aggregate relevant voting rights before testing an offer trigger.
- A member’s acquisition can affect the group and sometimes create an obligation for an individual member.
On this page9 sections
- Why the concert-party concept matters
- Cooperation to obtain or consolidate control
- Presumptions and associates
- How one member’s dealing can affect others
- Worked example: group below 30%
- Worked example: group between 30% and 50%
- How to build a concert-group analysis
- Relationship to disclosure and dealing obligations
- Common mistakes
- Exam
- LE Paper 17: Regulation of Takeovers and Share Buy-backs
- Format
- 40 computer-based multiple-choice questions
- Time
- 60 minutes
- Pass mark
- 70%
- Current guide
- Version 1.1, published December 2024
Why the concert-party concept matters
Takeover thresholds can apply to a person or a group acting in concert. If two or more people cooperate to obtain or consolidate control, the Code may treat their voting rights together for purposes of Rule 26. An individual holding below 30% may therefore be part of a group whose aggregate position is above it. The relevant question is not simply who signed the purchase contract.
The SFC Code defines acting in concert and includes presumptions for specified relationships. These rules support consistent analysis but are not a substitute for the underlying facts. A question may give family, corporate, advisory, financing or shareholder arrangements; determine which facts engage a presumption and whether the presumption can be rebutted under the Code. Do not assume every relationship automatically makes parties concert parties.
Cooperation to obtain or consolidate control
The concept focuses on cooperation toward obtaining or consolidating control. Parties can coordinate acquisitions, voting or other conduct in a way that meets the definition, even if their formal legal interests differ. The analysis concerns the purpose and effect of the cooperation, the timing of the relationship and relevant Code presumptions. An isolated common interest does not necessarily prove concert action.
The Code notes that shareholders may have acquired independently before they later come together to cooperate. Formation of a concert group can affect subsequent dealings and aggregate holdings. A scenario should therefore be read chronologically: what each party held before cooperation, when the group relationship arose and what acquisition followed. The answer can differ depending on whether a group existed at the time of the transaction.
Presumptions and associates
Presumptions simplify identification of relationships that commonly involve shared control interests, but the rules must be read carefully. The Code’s definitions of associates and persons acting in concert interact. Some categories presume concert action unless rebutted; other circumstances require an analysis of cooperation. Do not replace the Code’s precise categories with a broad intuition that “related parties count.”
In an exam problem, mark the relationship described and ask whether it falls within a stated presumption. Then check who is presumed to act with whom, what interests are aggregated and whether the facts address rebuttal. A company group, a financial adviser relationship or an arrangement with a shareholder may affect status under specific definitions. The exact Code text and notes control.
How one member’s dealing can affect others
Once parties act in concert, one member’s acquisition can move the group toward a trigger. Rule 26 also addresses situations in which one member acquires shares from another, and the individual allocation of interests may matter even if the group total is unchanged. A group cannot always avoid a consequence by treating each participant’s transaction as isolated.
The Code distinguishes acquisitions from a group member and acquisitions from a non-member in the context of holdings and the creeper. It addresses the 30% to 50% range and the 2% threshold over a 12-month period. The details include notes on disposals, transfer between members and the position of individual members. A simple group total is a starting point, not the complete calculation.
Worked example: group below 30%
Assume A holds 18% and B holds 10%. They later cooperate to obtain control and are treated as acting in concert, giving the group 28%. If B proposes to acquire another 2.5%, the group would hold 30.5%. The issue is whether that acquisition triggers Rule 26.1. The analysis also needs to establish when the group relationship arose, whether the interests count as voting rights and whether a waiver or note applies.
Now change the facts: A and B acquired independently, then later agreed to cooperate. Their combined existing shares at the point they come together total 28%. The Code addresses groups that form after independent acquisitions. Subsequent acquisitions are then analyzed under Rule 26 as a group. The date cooperation begins can therefore be as important as the date shares are acquired.
Worked example: group between 30% and 50%
Assume a concert group holds 37% and a member proposes further purchases. The 2% creeper may be relevant, but the candidate must examine the lowest percentage holding in the preceding 12 months and any acquisitions or disposals. If one member acquires from another, the individual holding can change even though the group aggregate remains 37%. The Code’s note on acquisitions among concert members may matter.
If the group sells shares and later buys back, do not automatically net the transactions. The Code specifies when disposals can affect the relevant baseline and whether netting is permitted. Record the dates and percentages in order, identify the holder and seller, then check the applicable note. Rounding a 1.99% movement to 2% can also obscure whether a threshold is crossed.
How to build a concert-group analysis
Create a table with one row for each person and columns for initial voting rights, relationship, event date, acquisition or disposal, resulting individual holding and resulting group holding. Mark when concert cooperation starts or ends. Then test the relevant trigger against the correct group and individual figures. This prevents a common error: adding shares from people who were not yet acting together when the acquisition occurred.
Next check the Code definitions and notes. Ask whether a presumption applies, who is within the relevant group, whether an associate’s interests count and whether a permitted exception or waiver is relevant. Where the problem mentions dilution, a share buy-back or an issue of new shares, examine the rule addressing an indirect percentage change. Avoid using only paid consideration or economic exposure if voting rights are what the rule measures.
Relationship to disclosure and dealing obligations
Concert status can affect more than a mandatory-offer trigger. It may influence dealing restrictions, disclosure obligations, offer documents and the treatment of associates. A person who is not the named offeror may still have relevant interests or disclosure duties. A candidate should identify status before analyzing whether a dealing occurred or what information must be disclosed.
The Code also treats fairness and equal treatment as central principles. Concert-party analysis can reveal whether a shareholder has received a special benefit or whether an offeror’s dealings affect price or consideration. A negotiated side arrangement may need separate analysis under the rules for special deals. Do not conclude that parties are free to agree privately simply because they are not the offeror and offeree.
Common mistakes
Common errors include counting a person’s interest before a concert relationship begins, ignoring a presumed concert party, applying the creeper to a group below 30%, treating a group acquisition as only the acquirer’s individual action, and netting disposals without checking the rule. Some problems intentionally distinguish the group’s percentage from an individual member’s percentage. Show both figures.
“Acting in concert” is a Code term. In a real transaction, status can require detailed factual analysis and consultation with the Executive. An exam answer should apply the stated facts and provisions, but should not present a simplified example as legal advice. Check the current SFC Codes and notes; guide version 1.1 may not include every later practice update.