Professional Scepticism for Sponsors: HKSI Paper 16
Professional scepticism means assessing information with a questioning mind.
- Sponsors should follow contradictions, test the reliability of sources and document why evidence supports a disclosure.
- It is disciplined inquiry, not an assumption of dishonesty.
| Signal | Question to investigate |
|---|---|
| Unusual customer payments | Who paid, why and what records corroborate the sale? |
| Concentrated customer | Is revenue sustainable and relationship accurately described? |
| One-off margin change | What caused it and is the narrative balanced? |
| Expert conclusion | What assumptions and source data support it? |
Follow contradictory evidence
Design questions that can reveal the mechanics behind a representation. “How much did you sell?” may produce an answer; “show the order, delivery, invoice, receipt and accounting entry for these transactions” tests how the sale occurred. Use samples selected with regard to concentration and risk, and record the basis for selection.
Watch for confirmation bias. If an early explanation seems plausible, continue checking evidence that could disprove it. Compare separate sources, interview relevant personnel and inspect terms that qualify the statement. A contrary fact should change the inquiry, not be treated as an inconvenience to the initial theory.
Use professional scepticism with expert reports too. Review the expert’s competence, scope and assumptions, ask whether source information is reliable and test whether conclusions fit other evidence. The sponsor need not become the expert, but must understand why reliance is reasonable and where the sponsor’s own judgment remains necessary.
A fair record distinguishes fact from inference. Note what the source directly establishes, what management explains and what the team concludes. State any residual uncertainty. This makes escalation more precise and prevents a later reviewer from mistaking an assumption for verified fact.
Additional Paper 16 guidance
Be alert to source dependence. An expert may rely on applicant data, so the sponsor should understand the underlying data and whether it has been verified. A third-party report is not independent confirmation if it repeats the same unsupported input.
Scepticism does not require investigating every immaterial detail indefinitely. Use reasonable judgment based on risk, materiality and context. Explain why the procedure addresses the concern and what limitation remains.
Common questions
Does scepticism mean assuming management is dishonest?
No. It means testing information with a questioning mind and responding to evidence that raises reliability concerns. It is disciplined inquiry, not an accusation.
What should happen when evidence conflicts?
Investigate the difference, seek corroboration, assess materiality, escalate unresolved matters and document the conclusion and disclosure impact.
Is a checklist enough?
A checklist can organize work, but it does not prove each statement is supported. The sponsor needs evidence and a reasoned assessment.