Sitonce
Country: US
Show exams for United States Hong Kong
Sign in

HKSI Paper 16 Sample Questions and Answers

Updated 4 min read
Key takeaway

These original scenarios explain public Paper 16 concepts and are not copied from HKSI’s live exam.

  • The strongest answer identifies the concern, the evidence needed and the sponsor representative’s responsibility.
  • They use public syllabus material to illustrate evidence-based sponsor actions.
Original practice: customer sales discrepancy

A major customer’s confirmation conflicts with the listing applicant’s reported sales. Which is the best next step for the sponsor representative?

  1. Accept the issuer’s explanation without more work.
  2. Investigate the difference, obtain corroboration and assess prospectus disclosure.
  3. Remove the customer from the business description.
  4. Ask an expert to certify the sales total.
Answer: B. The sponsor must apply professional scepticism, investigate contradictory evidence and maintain a reasonable basis for disclosure. An unexplored management assurance or expert signature is not enough.
Original practice: one-off rebate in MD&A

Management attributes a sustained margin increase to efficiency, but records show a one-time supplier rebate. What should the sponsor do?

  1. Leave the explanation as drafted.
  2. Verify the driver, assess materiality and ensure balanced MD&A.
  3. Delete all margin discussion.
  4. Rely only on the auditor’s report.
Answer: B. The narrative should accurately explain the financial driver, including material one-off effects. The sponsor should verify the claim and ensure the disclosure is not misleading.

Question: A major customer confirms purchases far below the listing applicant’s reported sales. What should the sponsor representative do? A. Accept management’s explanation without further work. B. Investigate the discrepancy, obtain corroborating evidence and assess the effect on disclosure. C. Remove the customer name only. D. Ask the expert to certify all sales. Answer B. Sponsor diligence requires critical inquiry and a reasonable basis for disclosure.

Question: A draft MD&A says margins improved because of operating efficiency, but cost records show a one-off supplier rebate. Which response is best? A. Leave the explanation unchanged. B. Verify the cause, quantify material effects and ensure MD&A is balanced and accurate. C. Delete all financial discussion. D. Rely on the auditor’s report alone. Answer B.

Question: Can an expert report by itself demonstrate that the sponsor discharged its due diligence? No. The sponsor should assess whether reliance is reasonable, understand relevant work and verify the disclosure; third-party work does not replace the sponsor’s own obligations.

Apply sponsor standards in context

Question: A major supplier will terminate a material agreement on a change of control, but the prospectus draft says the supplier relationship is stable. Which response is best? The representative should inspect the contract, assess the consequence, corroborate the business impact, escalate and ensure risk disclosure accurately reflects the termination right. A general supplier confirmation alone does not resolve the contractual condition.

Question: Management provides a spreadsheet showing customer sales, but the totals do not reconcile with audited statements. The representative should trace the period and accounting basis, investigate reconciling items, test source data and assess whether the discrepancy changes prospectus disclosure. Do not simply replace one total with another without understanding the difference.

Question: An expert report supports a market-size claim, but uses a definition that excludes a major competitor segment. The sponsor should understand the report’s scope, assumptions and source data, determine whether the claim in the prospectus matches that scope and assess whether qualification or revision is needed. Expert work does not make a broader statement reliable.

For each scenario, keep a response record: issue, primary source, evidence requested, result and disclosure implication. When practice explanations disagree, return to the current Code or Listing Rules and identify which proposition each source supports. This makes the exercise more useful than memorizing a letter.

Another scenario: a forecast assumes a rapid margin recovery, but recent management accounts show continued cost pressure. Verify the latest figures, test the assumptions and ensure the disclosure distinguishes historical results from forecasts and uncertainty. Do not use the forecast to obscure a current adverse trend.

Review the reasoning, not just the option. State what source or record would resolve the issue, who should conduct the work and what disclosure follows. If a practice explanation assumes facts not in the question, flag the assumption and revisit the problem.

Common questions

Are the questions official?

No. The examples are original teaching scenarios based on public syllabus concepts and are not represented as official or live HKSI exam questions.

What is the best answer to the customer discrepancy scenario?

Investigate the mismatch, seek corroborating evidence and assess whether prospectus disclosure must change. A management explanation alone may not resolve the issue.

Can an expert report replace sponsor diligence?

No. A sponsor must assess whether reliance is reasonable and retain its own evidential basis. Third-party work does not itself discharge sponsor obligations.