Time-weighted and Money-weighted Returns: HKSI Paper 12
Time-weighted return measures the compound performance of a portfolio while neutralizing external cash-flow timing.
- Money-weighted return is the internal rate of return on the investor’s actual cash flows.
- Paper 12 candidates should identify the question’s purpose and draw a timeline before calculating either measure.
On this page8 sections
- TWR
- Geometrically links subperiod returns; neutralises external cash-flow timing
- MWR
- IRR of dated investor cash flows; reflects amount and timing
- TWR asks
- How did the strategy perform?
- MWR asks
- What return did this investor experience?
- Syllabus
- Paper 12 Topic 3: portfolio returns and performance measurement
Two return measures, two different questions
Paper 12 includes return calculations and performance measurement. Time-weighted return (TWR) and money-weighted return (MWR) can both be useful, but they are not interchangeable. TWR measures portfolio performance while controlling for the effect of external cash flows. MWR calculates the rate that equates an investor's dated contributions and withdrawals with the ending value. It is an internal rate of return, so cash-flow timing affects it.
If a manager controls the investment decisions but not when a client adds or removes money, TWR is generally better for evaluating the manager's investment performance. If the question is what the investor earned on the capital actually deployed, MWR is relevant. A manager may deliver a strong first-period return, but the investor might contribute most of the money before a weak second period. TWR and MWR can diverge without either calculation being wrong.
Calculate time-weighted return
To calculate TWR, divide the total period at each external cash flow, calculate the portfolio return for each subperiod and geometrically link the results. For returns r1, r2 and so on, TWR = (1 + r1)(1 + r2)…(1 + rn) − 1. Value the portfolio immediately before each external flow if the data allow, so the flow itself is not mistaken for investment growth.
Consider an account worth HKD 1,000 at the start of the year. It grows to HKD 1,100 just before a midyear contribution of HKD 1,000. At year-end, the value is HKD 2,200. Period 1 return is (1,100 / 1,000) − 1 = 10%. After the contribution, HKD 2,100 is invested. Period 2 return is (2,200 / 2,100) − 1 = 4.7619%. The contribution is not profit; it is included in the starting value for period 2.
Link the subperiods: (1.10 × 1.047619) − 1 = 0.152381, or approximately 15.24%. Adding 10% and 4.7619% gives 14.7619%, which misses compounding. Multiply growth factors, then subtract one. If the question provides more periods, continue multiplying each factor.
| Period | Values | Return |
|---|---|---|
| Start to flow | 1,000 to 1,100 before contribution | 10.00% |
| Contribution | 1,000 added | External flow, not return |
| After flow to year-end | 2,100 to 2,200 | 4.7619% |
| Linked TWR | 1.10 × 1.047619 − 1 | 15.2381% |
The result removes the effect of the investor's decision to add money halfway through the year. It still includes the portfolio's performance after the contribution, because the new money is exposed to period 2. Exact time-weighted calculation requires valuations at the subperiod boundaries. When they are not available, a question may give a simplified method or ask you to calculate an approximation.
Calculate money-weighted return
MWR is the internal rate of return that balances dated investor cash flows with the ending value. From the investor's perspective, contributions are negative cash flows and withdrawals or final proceeds are positive. In the example, HKD 1,000 is contributed at time zero, HKD 1,000 halfway through the year and HKD 2,200 is received at year-end. Annual rate r solves 1,000(1+r) + 1,000(1+r)^0.5 = 2,200, using an accumulation-to-year-end convention.
Let y = square root of (1+r). Then y² + y − 2.2 = 0. The positive solution is about 1.06525. Squaring yields 1+r about 1.13475, so r is approximately 13.48%. Rounding can change the last decimal. This MWR is below the TWR of 15.24% because the extra contribution was invested only during the lower-return second period.
An IRR equation can require a calculator or numerical method when cash flows occur on irregular dates. On a multiple-choice exam, a timeline or answer choices may make the calculation manageable. Put contributions and withdrawals at their actual dates. Do not treat a halfway contribution as invested for the full year. Keep the cash-flow sign convention consistent throughout the equation.
Why the measures can disagree
Suppose a portfolio earns 20% in the first half and loses 10% in the second. TWR is (1.20 × 0.90) − 1 = 8%, not 10%. If most of an investor's money arrives before the loss, MWR may be below 8%. If most capital arrives before the strong first half and is withdrawn before the decline, MWR could be higher. The cash-flow schedule changes how much capital experiences each period.
This is why reports should state which measure they use. TWR helps compare a manager or strategy when client flows are outside the manager's control. MWR is more personal because it reflects the investor's actual cash-flow timing. Neither is best for every purpose. Choose the measure that matches the performance question.
Common calculation mistakes
A frequent mistake is counting a contribution as profit. If an account grows from 1,100 to 2,100 because the client added 1,000, that increase is cash invested, not return. Another error is adding subperiod percentages instead of linking growth factors. For MWR, an error is leaving out dates or signs. Write each contribution as an investor outflow and each withdrawal or ending value as an inflow before solving.
A return may also be nominal or real, annualised or cumulative, before or after fees. Paper 12 includes tax and inflation effects, so the reported investment return may not equal an investor's purchasing-power change. Read the question's measurement period and fee assumptions carefully. Do not compare a cumulative two-year return with a one-year rate as though they are on the same basis.
Original practice question
A portfolio earns 5% in the first subperiod and 10% in the second. What is the linked time-weighted return?
- 15.00%
- 15.50%
- 15.75%
- 16.00%
If an investor contributed a large amount only before the second subperiod, MWR would give more weight to that 10% return than to the first 5%. You need dated cash flows and values to calculate the exact MWR. Do not infer it from TWR alone. Different cash-flow schedules can produce different MWRs even when the portfolio earns the same subperiod returns.
How Paper 12 uses performance measurement
The Paper 12 syllabus expects candidates to calculate returns using various methods and evaluate performance. Return measurement supports comparison, monitoring and attribution, but each number needs context. Consider whether it is before or after fees, nominal or real, annualised or cumulative, and whether external cash flows affect it. The syllabus also covers tax and inflation, so a nominal return does not describe the investor's full change in purchasing power.
Use the current HKSI study guide for the exam's expected calculation conventions. This article uses original numbers rather than HKSI question examples. CFA Institute materials provide further professional-learning explanations of time-weighted and money-weighted measures. The public syllabus is version 3.7 and effective 1 November 2024; check HKSI's update page before your sitting for a later edition.
Draw a timeline before solving an internal rate of return
Money-weighted return is the rate that equates the present value of investor cash flows to the account outcome. Choose a sign convention, place contributions and withdrawals on their actual dates, and solve for the rate. A contribution is usually an outflow from the investor’s perspective and an inflow to the portfolio, so state which perspective the equation uses.
For a cash flow between measurement periods, the compounding exponent depends on the fraction of the period remaining. An approximation that places every flow at a period boundary can change the answer. The question’s timing convention controls. If the answer choices are close, check the timeline and equation before repeating arithmetic.
Money-weighted return may require solving a nonlinear equation and can have more than one mathematical root in unusual cash-flow patterns. Use the root that is economically meaningful for the stated problem and check the sign convention. For typical exam examples with one initial outflow and a later ending value, the intended rate is usually straightforward, but the timeline still controls the equation.